** Post your Top 50 ATG...list**

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MickyHatton
    PaThFiNdEr
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Nov 2005
    • 1611
    • 296
    • 462
    • 11,887

    #31
    Originally posted by Orishaman
    For that matter why JCC AT #3....or RJJ 11....
    Again my opinion, JCC is prominent in my memory as is RJJ so......where I had close decisions to make I used my personal experiences of a fighter instead of basing my opinion purely on what someone else has written about a fighter.

    Comment

    • MickyHatton
      PaThFiNdEr
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Nov 2005
      • 1611
      • 296
      • 462
      • 11,887

      #32
      Originally posted by Orishaman
      No bad, nice to see Matthew Franklin on the list!!, I debated but he is on the top 75 of my list Camamcho at 46 might be a little to early for him on mine...Chuvalo...maybe not....Foster at 42 to low, the most dominant LHW...deserve higher...
      Foster for me was a great fighter hence he is on the list but I feel the LHW division has been a weaker division throughout therefore that's where I see him!

      Comment

      • Mishra100
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jul 2005
        • 1330
        • 142
        • 63
        • 7,690

        #33
        Originally posted by MickyHatton
        You can ask that about many of my choices but that's the point there my choices!

        The featherweight division in my opinion has not been blessed with the standard of fighters throughout so therefore I have rated Pep at 21. But as I say its only my opinion.

        Its interesting that you noticed Pep's position but did not mention that Sandy Saddler is at 39 even though he was arguably as good as Pep, indeed he stopped Pep three times but lost once on points so.....its interpretation.
        I can only take 1 explaination at a time with that list.

        Comment

        • cyberthugpatrol
          Undisputed Champion
          • Oct 2006
          • 1541
          • 155
          • 106
          • 7,913

          #34
          estas mas pedo que la chingada !

          Originally posted by Orishaman
          1. SRR
          2. Henry Armstrong
          3. Ali
          4. Louis
          5. Henry Grebs
          6. Benny Leonard
          7. Pep
          8. Duran
          9. Monzon
          10. Johnson
          11. Moore
          12. SRL
          13. Hearns
          14. MMH
          15. Sammy Langford
          16. Mickey Walker
          17. Joe Gans
          18. Wilde
          19. Ezzard Charles
          20. Marciano
          21. Dempsey
          22. Foreman
          23. Tunney
          24. Bob Foster
          25. Sadler
          26. Eder Jofre
          27. Tony Zale
          28. Pernell Whitaker
          29. Kid Chocolate
          30. Nicolino Loche
          31. Basilio
          32. Kid Gavilan
          33. Barney Ross
          34. Alexis Arguello
          35. Jose Mantequilla Napoles
          36. Bob Fitzsimmons
          37. Pascual Perez
          38. Tony Canzzoneri
          39. Carlos Ortiz
          40. Wilfred Benitez
          41. Sal Sanchez
          42. Wilfredo Gomez
          43. LaMotta
          44. Billy Conn
          45. Abe Attel
          46. JCC
          47. Lou Ambers
          48. Antonio Cervantes
          49. Emil Griffith
          50. Stanley Ketchel

          Comment

          • Orishaman
            Contender
            • Jan 2004
            • 357
            • 19
            • 0
            • 6,669

            #35
            Originally posted by cyberthugpatrol
            estas mas pedo que la chingada !
            WTF ....dude translate

            Comment

            Working...
            TOP