** Post your Top 50 ATG...list**

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • !! $iN
    • Feb 2026
    • 0
    • 83
    • 0

    #11
    Originally posted by RunW/Knives
    Floyd isn't the greatest fighter of all time jackass.....so save it.

    Everyone can see you building up to that nonsense because he knocked out your favorite fighter and then beat Baldomir your second favorite fighter.

    He's nowhere near the top 30 all time or even 40 or 50.
    Get out of here with that ****. Floyd Mayweather right now is top 20 all-time at worst. He dominated everyone he fought. The only reason I don't have him top 5 is because his era was weak. He didn't have someone anywhere near his skill level at his best weights that was willing to step up. If he had a Duran, Hearns, and Leonard to face in this era at 130 or 135, he would be easily top 5 all-time...

    Comment

    • Orishaman
      Contender
      • Jan 2004
      • 357
      • 19
      • 0
      • 6,669

      #12
      1. SRR
      2. Henry Armstrong
      3. Ali
      4. Louis
      5. Henry Grebs
      6. Benny Leonard
      7. Pep
      8. Duran
      9. Monzon
      10. Johnson
      11. Moore
      12. SRL
      13. Hearns
      14. MMH
      15. Sammy Langford
      16. Mickey Walker
      17. Joe Gans
      18. Wilde
      19. Ezzard Charles
      20. Marciano
      21. Dempsey
      22. Foreman
      23. Tunney
      24. Bob Foster
      25. Sadler
      26. Eder Jofre
      27. Tony Zale
      28. Pernell Whitaker
      29. Kid Chocolate
      30. Nicolino Loche
      31. Basilio
      32. Kid Gavilan
      33. Barney Ross
      34. Alexis Arguello
      35. Jose Mantequilla Napoles
      36. Bob Fitzsimmons
      37. Pascual Perez
      38. Tony Canzzoneri
      39. Carlos Ortiz
      40. Wilfred Benitez
      41. Sal Sanchez
      42. Wilfredo Gomez
      43. LaMotta
      44. Billy Conn
      45. Abe Attel
      46. JCC
      47. Lou Ambers
      48. Antonio Cervantes
      49. Emil Griffith
      50. Stanley Ketchel

      Comment

      • Orishaman
        Contender
        • Jan 2004
        • 357
        • 19
        • 0
        • 6,669

        #13
        Originally posted by SiN
        Get out of here with that ****. Floyd Mayweather right now is top 20 all-time at worst. He dominated everyone he fought. The only reason I don't have him top 5 is because his era was weak. He didn't have someone anywhere near his skill level at his best weights that was willing to step up. If he had a Duran, Hearns, and Leonard to face in this era at 130 or 135, he would be easily top 5 all-time...

        Nope he is not...

        Comment

        • DiegoFuego
          Ask my dad, I'm GAY!
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Jan 2005
          • 17338
          • 1,403
          • 586
          • 24,657

          #14
          Originally posted by Orishaman
          1. SRR
          2. Henry Armstrong
          3. Ali
          4. Louis
          5. Henry Grebs
          6. Benny Leonard
          7. Pep
          8. Duran
          9. Monzon
          10. Johnson
          11. Moore
          12. SRL
          13. Hearns
          14. MMH
          15. Sammy Langford
          16. Mickey Walker
          17. Joe Gans
          18. Wilde
          19. Ezzard Charles
          20. Marciano
          21. Dempsey
          22. Foreman
          23. Tunney
          24. Bob Foster
          25. Sadler
          26. Eder Jofre
          27. Tony Zale
          28. Pernell Whitaker
          29. Kid Chocolate
          30. Nicolino Loche
          31. Basilio
          32. Kid Gavilan
          33. Barney Ross
          34. Alexis Arguello
          35. Jose Mantequilla Napoles
          36. Bob Fitzsimmons
          37. Pascual Perez
          38. Tony Canzzoneri
          39. Carlos Ortiz
          40. Wilfred Benitez
          41. Sal Sanchez
          42. Wilfredo Gomez
          43. LaMotta
          44. Billy Conn
          45. Abe Attel
          46. JCC
          47. Lou Ambers
          48. Antonio Cervantes
          49. Emil Griffith
          50. Stanley Ketchel
          keep going. you said Mayweather isn't top 90, *******. stop talking **** if you can't back it up on the spot.

          Comment

          • Run
            Outlaw
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Feb 2005
            • 56188
            • 2,588
            • 4,569
            • 76,412

            #15
            Originally posted by SiN
            Get out of here with that ****. Floyd Mayweather right now is top 20 all-time at worst. He dominated everyone he fought. The only reason I don't have him top 5 is because his era was weak. He didn't have someone anywhere near his skill level at his best weights that was willing to step up. If he had a Duran, Hearns, and Leonard to face in this era at 130 or 135, he would be easily top 5 all-time...
            Oh that's nonsense......top 20 at worst?

            Robinson
            Armstrong
            Gans
            Pep
            Louis
            Ali
            Leonard
            Duran
            Hagler
            Monzon
            Sadler
            Greb
            Tunney
            Jones Jr
            Foreman
            Foster
            Hearns
            Holyfield
            De La Hoya
            Hopkins


            All better fighters than Floyd.....oh and those aren't in any certain order whatsoever but those should easily be ahead of Floyd in the all time rankings.

            There's no way in hell you could make the case that Floyd is a better fighter than anyone on that list......that would be pure nuthugging.



            Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

            Comment

            • IwatchBoxing
              Banned
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Dec 2004
              • 10527
              • 235
              • 403
              • 11,555

              #16
              Not even if DLH beats Mayweather he gets into the top 20 lol

              Comment

              • Run
                Outlaw
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Feb 2005
                • 56188
                • 2,588
                • 4,569
                • 76,412

                #17
                Hell, Carmen Basilio was a much better welter than Floyd.



                Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

                Comment

                • Kball15
                  HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Apr 2006
                  • 15471
                  • 491
                  • 86
                  • 22,680

                  #18
                  Originally posted by Orishaman
                  1. SRR
                  2. Henry Armstrong
                  3. Ali
                  4. Louis
                  5. Henry Grebs
                  6. Benny Leonard
                  7. Pep
                  8. Duran
                  9. Monzon
                  10. Johnson
                  11. Moore
                  12. SRL
                  13. Hearns
                  14. MMH
                  15. Sammy Langford
                  16. Mickey Walker
                  17. Joe Gans
                  18. Wilde
                  19. Ezzard Charles
                  20. Marciano
                  21. Dempsey
                  22. Foreman
                  23. Tunney
                  24. Bob Foster
                  25. Sadler
                  26. Eder Jofre
                  27. Tony Zale
                  28. Pernell Whitaker
                  29. Kid Chocolate
                  30. Nicolino Loche
                  31. Basilio
                  32. Kid Gavilan
                  33. Barney Ross
                  34. Alexis Arguello
                  35. Jose Mantequilla Napoles
                  36. Bob Fitzsimmons
                  37. Pascual Perez
                  38. Tony Canzzoneri
                  39. Carlos Ortiz
                  40. Wilfred Benitez
                  41. Sal Sanchez
                  42. Wilfredo Gomez
                  43. LaMotta
                  44. Billy Conn
                  45. Abe Attel
                  46. JCC
                  47. Lou Ambers
                  48. Antonio Cervantes
                  49. Emil Griffith
                  50. Stanley Ketchel
                  WOW! you came up with alllllll that in under 40 mins!!!!

                  i mean, making a list of 50 is incredibly difficult. You got controversy and guys in different eras and weights. Its really tough. to do it in 40 mins is rediculous. The other guys probably had a list in mind or have been makin lists for a while.

                  nlol. U dont even know 50 fighters so making a valid list is close to impossible for you. You got that off google and we ALLLLLLLLLLLLLLL know it.

                  Do u even know who Lamotta fought besides Robinson?

                  Do u even know who sadler fought besides pep?

                  Do u even know who Tunney fought besides Dempsey?

                  Or better yet, do u even know who Dempsey fought besides Tunney?

                  Hell, u probably couldnt name ONE other opponent of george foreman besides ALI and Frazier without the help of BOXREC!!! lol

                  These matchups are probably all news to you. lol

                  But ull probably tell me other opponents by using BOXREC.com , but im sure u couldnt do it on ur own

                  Comment

                  • MickyHatton
                    PaThFiNdEr
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Nov 2005
                    • 1611
                    • 296
                    • 462
                    • 11,887

                    #19
                    1. Muhammad Ali
                    2. Sugar Ray Robinson
                    3. Julio Cesar Chavez
                    4. Joe Louis
                    5. Roberto Duran
                    6. Marvin Hagler
                    7. Thomas Hearns
                    8. Oscar De La Hoya
                    9. Sugar Ray Leonard
                    10. Alexis Arguello
                    11. Roy Jones Jr.
                    12. Henry Armstrong
                    13. George Foreman
                    14. Archie Moore
                    15. Larry Holmes
                    16. Jack Dempsey
                    17. Aaron Pryor
                    18. Evander Holyfield
                    19. Joe Frazier
                    20. Rocky Marciano
                    21. Willie Pep
                    22. Jake LaMotta
                    23. Matthew Saad Muhammad
                    24. Lennox Lewis
                    25. Carlos Monzon
                    26. Harry Greb
                    27. Bernard Hopkins
                    28. Salvador Sanchez
                    29. Pernell Whitaker
                    30. Jimmy Wilde
                    31. Jose Angel Napoles
                    32. Mike Tyson
                    33. Emile Griffith
                    34. Jack Johnson
                    35. Mickey Walker
                    36. Ruben Olivares
                    37. Benny Leonard
                    38. Ezzard Charles
                    39. Sandy Saddler
                    40. Jersey Joe Walcott
                    41. Eusebio Pedroza
                    42. Bob Foster
                    43. George Chuvalo
                    44. Barney Ross
                    45. Ted 'Kid' Lewis
                    46. Hector Camacho
                    47. Eder Jofre
                    48. Johnny Kilbane
                    49. Gene Tunney
                    50. Chris Eubank

                    Comment

                    • Rudyo
                      ...............
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • Jun 2006
                      • 10300
                      • 530
                      • 346
                      • 53,384

                      #20
                      My top 25 list took about 30 minutes to an hour to make.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP