PAC vs PBF -- who has the better resume?

[Chups]

This would be much better:


Manny Pacquiao:

Erik Morales (twice)
Marco Antonio Barrera
Juan Manuel Marquez [draw]
Oscar Larios
Chatchai Sasakul
Ledwaba




Floyd Mayweather:

Carlos Baldomir
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Jose Luis Castillo (twice)
Deigo Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Genero Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
Angel Manfredy



Floyd has a better resume.....it's just that it was a long time ago...the last 4 years competition belongs to Pac.

[Ta Khent]

now how ****** is that. compare floyd's resume to winky and see if you can say the same thing. they're in diff weight classes man

5lb difference. PAC weighed 141 on fight night...not out of the stretch of the imagination. Let me say again, Floyd's last five opponents at 135 would crush PAC.

[deliveryman]

To leave out Lehlo Ledwaba on Pac's record is ridiculous.

Ledwaba was a distinguished champion son.

The real question is "recently"...who has the best resume in the last 3 years?

Sorry, I KNEW I was forgetting someone.

[RE1600]

would pac be able to beat the fighters pbf has beaten and would pbf beat the fighters pacs beaten the answer is easy

[Chups]

would pac be able to beat the fighters pbf has beaten and would pbf beat the fighters pacs beaten the answer is easy

You mean would Chavez beat Pac's opponent in the flyweights?.....LOL!!

[Katz]

does PBF have a legend or future HOF on his resume?

[amagnin]

Pacquiao scores knockouts waaaaay above the weight class he started at.
Floyd Mayweather may not get a knockout for the rest of his career.
Don't say the win is all that matters...sometimes how you win is a big factor.
Oh, and I'd scratch Arturo and put Corley on that little list you got going.
Arturo is ****.

Overall Mayweather has the better resume.

I agree with you (especially when talking about two great fighters) that style matters. But the sport is not called Knockouts, its called boxing. Now if you were saying that Floyd is significantly more boring than Pac I wouldn't disagree at all. But if we're comparing them as fighters then excitement shouldn't really be a factor (I'm assuming that is why you think that Gatti is crap).

[flipbjefrox]

does PBF have a legend or future HOF on his resume?

the answer is no

[Katz]

the answer is no

oh yeah!!! therefore Pac has the better resume..

[bigtime9]

has floyd benn knocked the **** out before....has floyd lost before