PAC vs PBF -- who has the better resume?

[Ta Khent]

Manny Pacquiao:

Erik Morales (twice)
Marco Antonio Barrera
Juan Manuel Marquez [draw]
Oscar Larios
Chatchai Sasakul
Jorge Julio
Wethya Sakmuangklang


Floyd Mayweather:

Carlos Baldomir
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Jose Luis Castillo (twice)
Deigo Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Genero Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
Angel Manfredy

Floyd has, the last five opponents on Floyd's resume would absolutely crush PAC.

[-Antonio-]

I think its about even right now. Pacman destroyed a prime Barerra, and if he would have gotten that win over JMM it would be even more impressive.

[K-DOGG]

Manny Pacquiao:

Erik Morales (twice)
Marco Antonio Barrera
Juan Manuel Marquez [draw]
Oscar Larios
Chatchai Sasakul
Jorge Julio
Wethya Sakmuangklang


Floyd Mayweather:

Carlos Baldomir
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Jose Luis Castillo (twice)
Deigo Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Genero Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
Angel Manfredy

Overall, Mayweather's got the better resume; but over the last three years, Pacquiao does. You can't stay on top citing past glories.

[cyberthugpatrol]

Manny Pacquiao:

Erik Morales (twice)
Marco Antonio Barrera
Juan Manuel Marquez [draw]
Oscar Larios
Chatchai Sasakul
Jorge Julio
Wethya Sakmuangklang


Floyd Mayweather:

Carlos Baldomir
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Jose Luis Castillo (twice)
Deigo Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Genero Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
Angel Manfredy

........PBF

[cyberthugpatrol]

I....... Pacman destroyed a prime Barerra....

........wrong

[lesterprettyboy]

True...Marco was in his prime.He is just making all those flimsy excuses about being an "off-night"...MAB was I think top 3 in the P4P list at that time.He just beat Morales who was 41-0, Johny Tapia and Kevin Kelley before facing PAC...He was at the top of his game.Unfortunately, because of his past record and the type of beating inflicted by Manny, alot of people give credence to his alibi.

[cyberthugpatrol]

True...Marco was in his prime.He is just making all those flimsy excuses about being an "off-night"...MAB was I think top 3 in the P4P list at that time.He just beat Morales who was 41-0, Johny Tapia and Kevin Kelley before facing PAC...He was at the top of his game.Unfortunately, because of his past record and the type of beating inflicted by Manny, alot of people give credence to his alibi.

MAB was NOT in his prime

[Bonafide]

Very close and even Steven.

[lesterprettyboy]

MAB was NOT in his prime

Care to elaborate why?

[flipbjefrox]

I think Floyd has the better resume. People tend to forget just how dangerous Corrales, Castillo, Hernandez, and Chavez were considered to be. Not to mention Zab Judah whom, until he lost to Baldi, was everyone's pic to beat PBF.

The thing is, PBF fought a few bums in between and that tarnishes people's opinion of him. Manny has beaten Morales twice (an old Morales, but still Morales) and a blown-up Larios in his last three fights. That's very impressive in and of itself, but to add a TKO victory over Barrera (the only time Barrera's not gone the distance, not counting the DQ against Junior Jones) and a draw with JMM (which I thought JMM won) raises his stock in the public's view.

Manny has beaten these fighters recently while PBF's best competition was 7-10 years ago. The time factor makes it seem as if Manny has the better competition but I think it's PBF.

i see a lot of good fighters in PBF resume but i dont see a first ballot HOF unlike pacman