P4P championship Lineage

[Southpaw Stinger]

Thats my opinion, yes. I know people are gonna disagree, thats why im not gonna shove it down their throat

.... don't worry, I'm not gonna say anything. lol

[hellfire508]

Wow, Roy Jones Jr as P4P number 1? That's a big call. But you are entitled to say that. I hope you are not incorporating accomplishments though?

[cple]

Wow, Ray Robinson as P4P number 1? That's a big call. But you are entitled to say that. I hope you are not incorporating accomplishments though?

...because Ray Robinson didn't accomplish much? No matter what the criteria, Ray Robinson is, or should always be, in consideration for #1.

[hellfire508]

...because Ray Robinson didn't accomplish much? No matter what the criteria, Ray Robinson is, or should always be, in consideration for #1.

Sorry. I realised what I said. I was supposed to say Roy Jones at number 1. My mistake. I have Robinson at number 1.

[THE REAL NINJA]

Sugar Ray was not unbeatable. He lost just like everybody else.
What was the point of this? No one ever said he was .
And Roy Jones JR is #1.

Wow, Roy Jones Jr as P4P number 1? That's a big call. But you are entitled to say that. I hope you are not incorporating accomplishments though?

This is a list of the order in which fighters have been named p4p at in boxing mags and by fans ect, it is not a list of who I think was better .

[wmute]

Were Oscar and Tito p4p while Roy was unbeaten and dominating?

that sounds really weird

[THE REAL NINJA]

Were Oscar and Tito p4p while Roy was unbeaten and dominating?

that sounds really weird

Oscar took over during Roy's last years as a super middleweight
He was fighting lesser compatition and Oscar was fighting Whitaker ect.

Trinidad held it for a short time in some boxing mags after he beat Oscar,Reid,Vargas and Joppy.

[BKM-]

Old thread, i remember this one. What i should have said back then was, ability and not accomplishments. I still think Roy Jones JR would have been the most succesfull going up weight classes than anyone else, and one of the most gifted fighters ever. But he did not have the greatest career when it comes to accomplishments.

[wmute]

Oscar took over during Roy's last years as a super middleweight
He was fighting lesser compatition and Oscar was fighting Whitaker ect.

Trinidad held it for a short time in some boxing mags after he beat Oscar,Reid,Vargas and Joppy.

Roy was at SMW for 2 years (basically late 94-late 96)

Oscar fought Whitaker in 97.

Was Oscar p4p #1 in ring magazine, or was he p4p #1 like PacMan today?

[THE REAL NINJA]

Here is Ring Mags list


1989
Mike Tyson

1990 -92
Julio Cesar Chavez

1992-95
Pernell Whitaker

1996-98
Roy Jones, Jr.

1998
Oscar De La Hoya

1999
Roy Jones, jr.

2000-01
Shane Mosley

2002
Bernard Hopkins

2003
Roy Jones, Jr.

2004
Bernard Hopkins

2005-
Floyd Mayweather, Jr.

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.ph...Annual_Ratings



My point is that some of these years it was back and forth this just shows who ended up winning at the end of the year but someone else could have been the p4p champ at other times during each year.