Originally posted by billeau2
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Vitali
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by BKM-2010 View PostNo offense but it was the exact opposite. Lewis was landing bombs in the last 2 rounds of the fight as he found his range, that's why he won those rounds(and IMO I scored the fight 3-3). The famous uppercut ruined Vitali and by the end of the last round Lewis landed a punch to the temple which had Vitali staggering around the ropes.
People overanalyze Lewis sitting down on his stool. I believe that it is better for a fighter to be worn out because of stamina related issues as a pro will likely find a second wind, compared to being worn out because of punishment that they have taken. The latter is something that fighters rarely recover from during a fight, and there is no doubt that Vitali took the most damage of the fight whereas Lewis had only been hurt in round 2 and was literally walking through Vitali's punches in the last couple of rounds with no care.
Yes THAT upper cut was huge and Vitali was wobbled but Vitali recovered, was up on points in like 90% of cards and had landed big, BIG shots on Lewis.
I have always maintained that the fight should have gone on for at least another round, if Vitali looked in trouble again, then fair enough, stop it. But it was for THE heavyweight championship of the world, the biggest prize in sport, there could have been a historic moment yet the ref stopped it just when the fight was lighting up!
The one thing that can tell who you was winning the fight or who did win the fight are the fighters reactions. Lewis was upset after the fight, at the booes, at the interviewers questions, all his answers were passive aggressive and he kept going back and forth on whether or not there would be a rematch. Kinda like Froch/Bradley/Duran and all those who have lost when they weren't supposed to or gotten dodgy decisions.
Where as Vitali was honest and straight to the point because he knew what the fight was like, "I want the rematch, I feel like the people's champ".
Comment
-
Originally posted by BattlingNelson View PostIt would depend upon how greatness is defined. In fantasy head to head matchups, he'll absolutely rank up there.
Comment
-
Originally posted by soul_survivor View PostI'll look at that fight again but having seen it only once since it was live (about 3 years ago or so) and both times I came away with the impression that Lewis was looking faded, slow and out of breath.
Yes THAT upper cut was huge and Vitali was wobbled but Vitali recovered, was up on points in like 90% of cards and had landed big, BIG shots on Lewis.
I have always maintained that the fight should have gone on for at least another round, if Vitali looked in trouble again, then fair enough, stop it. But it was for THE heavyweight championship of the world, the biggest prize in sport, there could have been a historic moment yet the ref stopped it just when the fight was lighting up!
The one thing that can tell who you was winning the fight or who did win the fight are the fighters reactions. Lewis was upset after the fight, at the booes, at the interviewers questions, all his answers were passive aggressive and he kept going back and forth on whether or not there would be a rematch. Kinda like Froch/Bradley/Duran and all those who have lost when they weren't supposed to or gotten dodgy decisions.
Where as Vitali was honest and straight to the point because he knew what the fight was like, "I want the rematch, I feel like the people's champ".
Comment
-
Originally posted by BKM-2010 View PostYeah you should definitely rewatch the fight as well as the interviews afterwards 'cause you have many things backwards. Vitali was completely deluded and out of control. He almost caused a riot and was saying that Lewis never hit him with any hard punch once and that every one of the cuts were caused by headbutts and things like that. Lewis I feel was being attacked by Larry Merchant and was merely defending himself, and in a classy way as well. But the constant "Look at the state of his face" is hilarious though lol.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Weltschmerz View PostAgreed. Greatness should be measured on more than just resume. Ali's greatness was measured on more than just resume, for instance.
Ali's greatness is based is based on what Ali actually did. Not fantasy fights based on opinions that can never be proven one way or the other. You can't even compare the two situations.
The fact remains Vitali failed against the best opponents he faced. You can make all of the excuses you want, but he lost. Other than that, he doesn't have a single win over a fighter that would even qualify for the watered down boxing hall of fame.
There is nothing great about that no matter how you try to spin it. You would be better off arguing a case for his brother. But Vitali is no where near great and doesn't even belong in any kind of all time great discussion.
Comment
-
Originally posted by soul_survivor View PostVitali is a great of his era but in the second half of his career, his opposition has faded, with the last few fights being laughable at best.
In terms of the whole Lewis/Vitali argument, Lewis was badly faded by the end of the 4th, Vitali was landing huge shots on him and yes Vitali was cut but white fighters normally cute faster anyway. Lewis was all but done when he sat on hs stool at the end of the 6th, you could see it on his face when the fight was called off, the relief damn.
Lewis didn't fight again because he knew he was done.
for the sake of discussion, let's say that your assessment of the fight is spot on.
does that negate the fact that clean punches opened up vitali's face and prompted a very appropriate stoppage?
Comment
-
Originally posted by joseph5620 View PostAli's greatness is based is based on what Ali actually did. Not fantasy fights based on opinions that can never be proven one way or the other. You can't even compare the two situations.
The fact remains Vitali failed against the best opponents he faced. You can make all of the excuses you want, but he lost. Other than that, he doesn't have a single win over a fighter that would even qualify for the watered down boxing hall of fame.
There is nothing great about that no matter how you try to spin it. You would be better off arguing a case for his brother. But Vitali is no where near great and doesn't even belong in any kind of all time great discussion.
Vitali belongs among the greats.
Comment
Comment