Who hit harder, Tyson or Marciano?

[leff]

tyson hit harder then marciano for sure, 180lb hard puncher vs a 220lb hard puncher, the 220lb has to win. ill tell u dis, there are time where a 140lb fighter can hit harder then a 200lb fighter but dats coz the 140lb fighter has a decastating punch and the 200lb fighter has a crap punch. if u get 2 guys who both punch very hard for their weight, then its common sense to say the heavier will hit harder. but it cant be 100% certain unless if their was a force machine or sumthing which they both yoused.

i perfectly understande your logic.

but has alot to do with genetics and the way you throw a punch,tyson had lightning fast combos whilst marciano had slow one blow at the, they both had a very high percentage off ko`s, so i would have to gove the hardest punch to marciano,BUT it doesnt mean he is more dangerous than
tyson is.

[machotime]

I really feel that Marciano hit way harder. The man broke arms, crushed bones and had a chin of steel. Both Tyson and Marciano hit hard, but raw punching power has to go to Marciano.

[butterfly1964]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

butterfly

im gonna repeat my question

do you box yourself?

also what exactly do you mean by natural weight?

no, i don't box myself. and natural weight is the weight that a fighter is most comfortable in. packing on pounds, even if it is muscle does not help punching power or chin if your body requires a smaller weight. it all depends on your frame.

[leff]

i thought so, cause whan you fight you soon realize that punching power mainly comes from technic and leverage, if you did box you would know that 180 man can punch harder than a 220man.

hell ive seen guys at 120 punch harder than 220.both active fighters.


also to the natural weight think you say many off this guys was former lightheavys and middlewieght and they where not at their natural wieght.

walcot turned pro at 16 and its natural fore a guy to weigh more at age 35 than age 16.

[butterfly1964]

i thought so, cause whan you fight you soon realize that punching power mainly comes from technic and leverage, if you did box you would know that 180 man can punch harder than a 220man.

hell ive seen guys at 120 punch harder than 220.both active fighters.


also to the natural weight think you say many off this guys was former lightheavys and middlewieght and they where not at their natural wieght.

walcot turned pro at 16 and its natural fore a guy to weigh more at age 35 than age 16.

alright, i'll give you that one. but charles and moore were definetely blown up.

[Skydog]

Tyson isn't even known for his punching power. It was the speed of his hands that got him so many KO's. Rocky didn't have that fast of hands, and destroyed people. Like NextRocky has told us, he put a guy in a coma and paralyzed half of someone's body. Someone he fought (I can't remember who) tried to cover up with their arms and got one of the broken.

One of you guys find me a punch of Tyson's that even comes close to the right Marciano landed on Walcott.

[butterfly1964]

Tyson isn't even known for his punching power. It was the speed of his hands that got him so many KO's. Rocky didn't have that fast of hands, and destroyed people. Like NextRocky has told us, he put a guy in a coma and paralyzed half of someone's body. Someone he fought (I can't remember who) tried to cover up with their arms and got one of the broken.

One of you guys find me a punch of Tyson's that even comes close to the right Marciano landed on Walcott.

michael jack johnson.

[Skydog]

Damn, your right. But still, I don't think it such an impact on Johnson as Marciano's did on Walcott. Walcott's face is grotesque when he is hit, and as Bert Sugar called it, "Walcott's face was turned to pudding."

[butterfly1964]

Damn, your right. But still, I don't think it such an impact on Johnson as Marciano's did on Walcott. Walcott's face is grotesque when he is hit, and as Bert Sugar called it, "Walcott's face was turned to pudding."

depends on how the face is positioned. marciano probably hit hit him where the most skin was.

[Da Iceman]

i havent seen that fight so can you tell me exactly what happend when he knocked him out was he unconcious ?