Robbery!!

[Da Iceman]

larry holmes was robbed! he shouldve been #3 instead of dempsey, and charles shouldnt of even been on the list, what they hell did he do at heavyweight except beat a 127 year old louis and lose to marciano and walcott.

if walcott beat charles shouldnt he be on the list too?

[butterfly1964]

larry holmes was robbed! he shouldve been #3 instead of dempsey, and charles shouldnt of even been on the list, what they hell did he do at heavyweight except beat a 127 year old louis and lose to marciano and walcott.

if walcott beat charles shouldnt he be on the list too?

actually, charles beat walcott 2 out of 3 times, so charles is better.

[M26]

My heavyweight list:

1. Joe Louis
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Rocky Marciano
4. George Foreman
5. Larry Holmes
6. Jack Dempsey
7. Gene Tunney
8. Joe Frazier
9. Sonny Liston
10. Mike Tyson

I don't know enough about guys like Jack Johnson or Jeffries to have them on my list.

[czars_salad]

if you watched classic ringside: bert suger's top ten heavyweights, you have just witnessed the biggest robbery in the history of boxing! why, do you ask? well, here's the list.

10. larry holmes
9. joe frazier
8. george foreman
7. ezzard charles
6. rocky marciano
5. gene tunney
4. jack johnson
3. jack dempsey
2. muhammad ali
1. joe louis

they actually put thee greatest at #2! bert sugar is the closest thing to john dilinger that i know, thanks to this list. this is an outrage! ali is the greatest, was the greatest, and always be the greatest! joe louis would get destroyed by ali, even sugar admitted this, but the criteria he judged this on was the biggest bull i ever heard. i'm furious! aren't you?

it's just an opinion dude... being the best is always a subjective issue

[leff]

My heavyweight list:

1. Joe Louis
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Rocky Marciano
4. George Foreman
5. Larry Holmes
6. Jack Dempsey
7. Gene Tunney
8. Joe Frazier
9. Sonny Liston
10. Mike Tyson

I don't know enough about guys like Jack Johnson or Jeffries to have them on my list.

that list is ****ing brilliant,wouldnt change it much, id say out with tyson and in with holyfield and its about perfect.

[Mr. Violence]

if you watched classic ringside: bert suger's top ten heavyweights, you have just witnessed the biggest robbery in the history of boxing! why, do you ask? well, here's the list.

10. larry holmes
9. joe frazier
8. george foreman
7. ezzard charles
6. rocky marciano
5. gene tunney
4. jack johnson
3. jack dempsey
2. muhammad ali
1. joe louis

they actually put thee greatest at #2! bert sugar is the closest thing to john dilinger that i know, thanks to this list. this is an outrage! ali is the greatest, was the greatest, and always be the greatest! joe louis would get destroyed by ali, even sugar admitted this, but the criteria he judged this on was the biggest bull i ever heard. i'm furious! aren't you?

I totally agree...Ali was the greatest and would KO Joe Louis. Louis would not know what to do with Ali's movement and speed.

[Da Iceman]

i really doubt ali had the power to stop louis

[Da Iceman]

but walcott finaly beat him, and from what i saw walcott won that fight

[fabulous]

Is this Ali's nuthuggers site? Ali the greatest? You shouldn't believe all what Ali has said, he is self proclaimed greatest
Ali is top 3 alltime HW but no wonder old timers rate Louis higher, Ali was techically flawed fighter and got too much by cheating(in his late career).

[Da Iceman]

Is this Ali's nuthuggers site? Ali the greatest? You shouldn't believe all what Ali has said, he is self proclaimed greatest
Ali is top 3 alltime HW but no wonder old timers rate Louis higher, Ali was techically flawed fighter and got too much by cheating(in his late career).

hit the nail right on the head