Greater fighter, Sandy Saddler or Maxie Rosenbloom?

[Barn]

had to be done irondan

[IronDanHamza]

Sandy Saddler is up there amongst my favourite fighters.

But there is just absolutely no way he is greater than Maxie Rosenbloom.

No way.

[McGoorty]

Sandy Saddler is up there amongst my favourite fighters.

But there is just absolutely no way he is greater than Maxie Rosenbloom.

No way.

I have to give Maxie the edge,.... just so many great names that he beat, and his losses are mostly to ATG's.... he has to have a number of losses, you see how many fights he had, insane........ He had virtually no power whereas Saddler has dynamite, and that's why he edges Sandy out,.. but not by that much,... Saddlers power id a plus, without it, Slapsie would be further ahead....... just a phenomenal record.