What do youu guys think about the juding of the barrera vs marquez fight?

[gatorDelux]

What do youu guys think about the juding of the barrera vs marquez fight?

Just watched it again and i thought barrera won it by one point because of the point deduction for hitting marquez while down.

it was a damn close fight and i wouldnt have cried had marquez won it close but the 118-109 and twice 116-111 seemed dhiitty to me.

i thought barrera definatly should have been given credit for the knockdown and the point deduction seemed fair enpugh to me aslo making it 9-8 round?

all that stuff being said great close fight between two great fighters.

[IronDanHamza]

Judging was outright terrible.

I did have Marquez winning but those scocards are a joke.

Barrera should have been credited with a KD aswell.

[gatorDelux]

Judging was outright terrible.

I did have Marquez winning but those scocards are a joke.

Barrera should have been credited with a KD aswell.

if he was credited with the knockdown would you have have still had it for barrera? i also thought the point deduction was just.

[IronDanHamza]

if he was credited with the knockdown would you have have still had it for barrera? i also thought the point deduction was just.

You mean would I still have had it for Marquez?

I haven't scored it in a while and can't recall my actual score card but I had it close so maybe.

I'll re-score it tommorow and post it in there with and without the KD.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Every round was close so I don't see why a wide margin in the scorecards is a big deal.

[Scott9945]

JMM won that fight, no matter how painful it was to HBO's announcers.