Carl Froch vs James Toney @ 168lb

[Perfect Plex]

Who wins & how?

[Rockin']

James at 168lbs will destroy Froch. Not a thing that Froch does better than James. James Toney UD Carl Froch..........Rockin'

[The_Demon]

Toney counters him too death,id be surprised if froch landed more than four clean punches the whole fight.JT would likely win a lopsided decision but it wouldnt shock me if he stopped froch late

[blaze778]

As much as I like Froch, he is not in Toney's league.

Toney by wide Decision.

I can't see Froch getting stopped, but he would be lucky to win 2 rounds.

[Mistadobalina]

toney would end him imo. froch is too easy to hit and 168lb version of toney could be very, very busy.

froch has the advantage as far as length and he has a good, long jab when he puts it out there, but he just doesn't have the boxing mind to overcome someone with toney's style. at the end of the day, froch will end up getting into a shootout resulting in a KO loss via a punch he didn't see coming.

[BigStereotype]

Toney absolutely humiliates Froch. It's not even close, Toney by wide UD, maybe stoppage.

[Heeb]

Froch gets shut out. Two different classes of fighters.

[Joeyzagz]

Toney absolutely humiliates Froch. It's not even close, Toney by wide UD, maybe stoppage.

Froch is the Sebastian Bach of fighters. He would hit Toney's dome with an arpeggio of Jabs, and Toney's rollie-pollie ass will be dumbfounded, and probably quit on his stool. Im picking Froch by Unanimous decision.

[JAB5239]

Froch is the Sebastian Bach of fighters. He would hit Toney's dome with an arpeggio of Jabs, and Toney's rollie-pollie ass will be dumbfounded, and probably quit on his stool. Im picking Froch by Unanimous decision.

Come on now Zagz.....back to reality!

[slicksouthpaw16]

I could see Froch outworking a lazy Toney but Toney on his best night i think would be a bit too quick handed IMO at the end of the day and would probably be a bit too sharp with his counters. Toney was flat footed so i don't see him embarrassing Froch with any foot speed but i think he lands at a higher connect rate and frustrates him with his head movement and inside game. It wouldn't be a whitewash though, Ive seen Toney struggle at 168 and Froch has pretty significant advantages in height and reach. Froch also has 12 round stamina (and is a better boxer than given credit for IMO). I see a 116-112 type decision in Toney's favor.