Which of these UK boxers is a bonafide ATG in your opinion?

[SBleeder]

I'm surprised there isn't more love for Randy Turpin - the man beat a prime Sugar Ray Robinson and became the undisputed middleweight champion.

Prime my foot. Robinson was by no means shot when they fought but it was hardly his true prime.

[Barn]

Lewis and Wilde obviously and Welsh,

[the_ilest]

From recent times.

Lewis, Hamed and Calzaghe are all ATGs.

lewis yes. hahahahhah hamed and calzaghe. thats funny.

[mrboxer]

i dont think any of these fighters have done enough to be considered an all time great,

[Obama]

Tommy Farr should be on that list. He is the only HW that Prime Joe Louis could not KO....arguably beat a prime Joe Louis.[/IMG]

No one argues that. But I do agree he's of the caliber of some fighters on the list.

Appalling that Joe Calzaghe has 2x the votes of Freddie Welsh. Just goes to show the lack of knowledge here. Lewis having 3x the votes is pretty bad too. People really have no concept of pound for pound.

Ken Buchanan also should have made the list.

[KlownvonnomaD]

I'd say maybe Jim Watt and Barry Mcguigan could be considered as well.

I voted Lewis, Turpin, Eubanks and Calz.