Hopkins vs Calzaghe:Are their resumes similiar

[Toney616]

Small Oscar < Undefeated Jeff Lacy

Interesting.
Oscar best win at mw
Felix Sturm(gift decision)
Lacys best wins at smw:
Reid

blown up Pavlik < Prime Sakio Bika

I dont know what to make of the Pavlik win, what does it mean when the no 1 ranked lhw beats the no 1 ranked mw?

Shot Winky < Berenard Hopkins

Hopkins vs Wright was garbage, he gets no credit for that

SHot Roy Jones < 2008 Roy Jones

I would argue that Jones was pretty much shot by 2008, but at least he was on a winning streak and Calzaghe outworked him. When Hopkins got to him, he was coming off a loss by way of ko and was headbutted and rabbit punched over 12 rounds. Jones also got paid for fighting Calzaghe

Tarver < ATG Chris Eubank

Interesting

Small Trinidad < Prime Mikkel Kessler

I can agree with this. Kassler's best win at smw is over Froch. Tito's best win is over Joppy

Also
No contests:
Calzaghe:0
Hopkins:1
Hopkins jumped out of the ring against Allen and faked that injury so he could keep his belt
Draws:
Calzaghe:0
Hopkins:1
What is Hopkins doing drawing with journeyman like Mercado?
Losses:
Calzaghe:0
Hopkins:Mitchell, Taylor I, Taylor II, Jones, Calzaghe

[NinjaMan!]

Lets be honest here, Hopkins was a 6'2 LHW who made his name fighting WELTERWEIGHTS. There is no comparison whatsoever, and Calzaghe's resume is superior based on him fighting guys his own size.

Let's face facts here. Light heavyweights don't weigh in at 157 when there 40 years old. Nice try though.

[Toney616]

Joe Calzaghe smw resume:
Journeymen:
Branko Sobot Juan Carlos Gimenez Ferreyra Rick Thornberry David Starie Omar Sheika Richie Woodhall Mario Veit Will McIntyre Miguel Angel Jimenez Tocker Pudwill Mger Mkrtchyan Kabary Salem Mario Veit Evans Ashira Peter Manfredo Jr
Contenders:
Robin Reid Charles Brewer Byron Mitchell Jeff Lacy Sakio Bika
Top contenders:
Mikkel Kessler
Bernard Hopkins mw resume:
Journeymen:
Steve Frank Joe Lipsey William Bo James John David Jackson Andrew Council Simon Brown Robert Allen*3 Syd Vanderpool Carl Daniels Morrade Hakkar Howard Eastman
Contenders:
Antwun Echols*2 Glen Johnson William Joppy Oscar De La Hoya
Top contenders:
Felix Trinidad

Im sure some names can be moved around, but the basic outline would stay the same