Calzaghe vs G-Man

[T.McGrady]

Prime vs Prime who'd get the W?

[#1Assassin]

McClellan by manslaughter wasnt an option so i picked by KO.

[TheMagicMan]

McClellan by manslaughter wasnt an option so i picked by KO.

Uhh...you mixed up the names. Joe C wins every fantasy matchup because hes the GOAT.

[sonnyboyx2]

Gerald walks chases him down within 2rds leaves JC spreadeagled on the canvas "Face-Down"

[TheMagicMan]

Gerald walks chases him down within 2rds leaves JC spreadeagled on the canvas "Face-Down"

You clearly have never watched Joe Calzaghe fight, your opinion is worthless, delete your account, start over. Who has ever had to chase Joe down? Just tell me a moment in a fight where Joe was retreating? In 46 fights, just one moment where he wasnt coming forward. It didnt matter if he was just knocked down, if he was killing a big puncher like Eubank on the cards, Kessler etc...Joe always came forward. So the fact that you say someone would have to chase him means you know nothing about boxing.

[Stone Roses!]

Gerald McClellan would KO Joe Calzaghe.

Grandpa Hopkins and Grandpa Jones dropped Joe in the 1st round. Imagine what a prime Gerald will do to Joe Calzaghe.

Calzaghe's best wins:

• Chris Eubank - Past Prime
• Bernard Hopkins - Past Prime
• Roy Jones Jr - Shot, Past Prime
• Jeff Lacy - Prime C-Class Fighter
• Mikkel Kessler - Great Fighter in his Prime

Props to Calzaghe for beating Kessler. It was an entertaining fight too. Watched it again a couple days ago.

*Awaits a retort from TheMagicMan*

[JK1700]

I would lean towards Gerald because Calzaghe never fought a true explosive puncher. Well, Lacy was considered a big puncher but I dont think you can compare him with the G-Man.

[Tyson.]

Gerald McClellan would KO Joe Calzaghe.

Grandpa Hopkins and Grandpa Jones dropped Joe in the 1st round. Imagine what a prime Gerald will do to Joe Calzaghe.

Calzaghe's best wins:

• Chris Eubank - Past Prime
• Bernard Hopkins - Past Prime
• Roy Jones Jr - Shot, Past Prime
• Jeff Lacy - Prime C-Class Fighter
• Mikkel Kessler - Great Fighter in his Prime

Props to Calzaghe for beating Kessler. It was an entertaining fight too. Watched it again a couple days ago.

*Awaits a retort from TheMagicMan*

Calzaghe was past prime when he was dropped by Hopkins/Jones. Calz was moving up in weight for these fights and his prime is not at LHW. He was only dropped once at SMW, where he then came of the canvus to KO his opponent. His chin was good.

Calzaghe was unlucky to be in an era after Eubank, Collins, Benn and Watson. Most say that Calzaghe would have beaten those fighters in thier prime.

Lacy wasnt a C class fighter, he was touted as the new mike tyson. Its the beating that Calz gave him and the injuries that turned him into a C class fighter.

Calzaghe has a better resume than Mccellan does.

[T.McGrady]

Calzaghe was past prime when he was dropped by Hopkins/Jones. Calz was moving up in weight for these fights and his prime is not at LHW. He was only dropped once at SMW, where he then came of the canvus to KO his opponent. His chin was good.

Calzaghe was unlucky to be in an era after Eubank, Collins, Benn and Watson. Most say that Calzaghe would have beaten those fighters in thier prime.

Lacy wasnt a C class fighter, he was touted as the new mike tyson. Its the beating that Calz gave him and the injuries that turned him into a C class fighter.

Calzaghe has a better resume than Mccellan does.

If calzaghe tried to exchange with G-Man, he'd go down early. Calzaghe never fought a fighter as powerfull as mcclellan.

[The_Demon]

If calzaghe fought smart for the first half of the fight when g-man was at his most dangerous he would win a decision,my only worry would be that calz would end up getting into a war early and get knocked out,the first few rounds being very dangerous for him