Poll....Higher On A ATG List Robinson Or Ali?

[Southpaw Great]

This should be interesting....The officail Ali vs Robinson poll. Who in YOUR OPINION should rank higher on a ATG list?

[NChristo]

Easy decision for me, Sugar Ray Robinson, I don't even have Ali in my top 10.

[boxing boy]

Easy decision for me, Sugar Ray Robinson, I don't even have Ali in my top 10.

I agree with SRR,he is head and shoulders better than Muhammad Ali.

Who are the 9 fighters you have above Muhammad Ali?

[NChristo]

I agree with SRR,he is head and shoulders better than Muhammad Ali.

Who are the 9 fighters you have above Muhammad Ali?

At the moment my top 10 is:

(Random order)
Ray Robinson
Joe Gans
Harry Greb
Willie Pep
Sam Langford
Henry Armstrong
Jimmy Wilde
Archie Moore
Benny Leonard
Roberto Duran

Changes on a daily basis
(I could easily change 2 or 3 names on there for Charles, Fitzsimmons etc, depends on how I'm feeling )

If I put enough thought into making a fixed list longer then 10 I guess Ali would be around 16 - 18.

[wiseman]

Ali is greater, but I can see why others would rank Robinson higher.

Unfortunately, you'll find a lot of yes-boy's who rank Robinson higher because "that's how it's supposed to be".

[Marcov]

They both are top 5 but I have Robinson #1

[boxing boy]

At the moment my top 10 is:

(Random order)
Ray Robinson
Joe Gans
Harry Greb
Willie Pep
Sam Langford
Henry Armstrong
Jimmy Wilde
Archie Moore
Benny Leonard
Roberto Duran

Changes on a daily basis
(I could easily change 2 or 3 names on there for Charles, Fitzsimmons etc, depends on how I'm feeling )

If I put enough thought into making a fixed list longer then 10 I guess Ali would be around 16 - 18.

Thank you for your top 10 list.I respect your opinion,but i have Ali in the top 5.
But we both agree what this thread is about.SRR is the greatest fighter ever p4p.

[carlos slim]

ali is the better fighter in his prime since he had good footwork like robinson but also had amazing head movement....i could care less about some random quote by ali saying robinson was the greatest....ali in his prime>robinson in his prime....i can picture prime ali beating every heavyweight i cant do the same for robinson at welterweight or middleweight...

[paulsinghnl]

Robinson can get any style, he would adapt and box or fight hard, he would always try to dominate, if not the first fight, then the second/third/fourth/fifth. Ali had one style, he was dominating boxing forward or backwards laterally, Robinson could actually push the action, he could be brutally violent, u can't say that about Ali, although Ali worked hard and was fast as hell!

i don't know, them at some same weight in some fantasy world, it's Robinson's aggressiveness that has the edge for me that would eat him up, his aggressiveness forward and backward, if u understand what i mean.

[Sugarj]

I cant split them so I've chosen not to vote.