Higher On A ATG List. Charley Burley Or Bernard Hopkins?

[Southpaw Great]

Well? and state reason behind your answer.

[JAB5239]

Well? and state reason behind your answer.

Burley without question. He simply beat the far better fighters. Burley holds wins over prime Archie Moore and Holman Williams. Hopkins has nothing close to that.

[louis54]

burley sameas above. baaaaad mf

[General Zod]

Well? and state reason behind your answer.

Dont know much about Burley, what kind of fighter was he and who did he beat? As for Hopkins he isnt a ATG imo

[Obama]

They should be rated pretty close to each other either way you go. Burley got better wins but Hopkins was far, far more consistent. It's not just about how good you are on your best day.

[JAB5239]

They should be rated pretty close to each other either way you go. Burley got better wins but Hopkins was far, far more consistent. It's not just about how good you are on your best day.

True, but do you not think it's worth taking into consideration that Burley had chronic hand problems for much of his career?

[Obama]

True, but do you not think it's worth taking into consideration that Burley had chronic hand problems for much of his career?

Worth taking that into account for talking about ATG talents...not careers. If we talk about the most talented fighters of all time then Burley can be rated way ahead of Hopkins.