Is Manny Pacquiao an all-time great?

[Obama]

If Mayweather gets credit for cracking Hattons' chin...doesn't Pac get cerdit for adding significant miles to JMM's odomoeter before he agreed to be a well paid, chubby tune up with no hope of winning against Floyd? What about the battles with MAB, Casa, and Diaz?

Yes.

Maybe it's because you're trying to personally discredit a fighter's best wins with a fighter that you think of more highly.

Stop assuming things. You don't know me.

I can just as easily discredit Mayweather's wins against Genaro Hernandez, Gatti, Mitchell, Judah, DLH, and Marquez, who had all seen better days. And that's just off the top of my head.

[dionysius]

They have like up to 20 rounds before now it was reduced to 12 rounds... Do you think that Manny can do 20 rounds of boxing? Like in his fight with marquez?

If he can, then he is an all time great after he defeats Cotto.