Holyfield vs Frazier who wins

[Big Idiot]

frazier had a very good chin in my opinion, just look at thrilla in manilla, both are great fighters with good chins, but holyfield would win with his better experience

[GJC]

frazier had a very good chin in my opinion, just look at thrilla in manilla, both are great fighters with good chins, but holyfield would win with his better experience

I don't know where this fallacy started about Frazier having a bad chin.

[Dynamite Kid]

No one is saying he has a bad chin just that Holyfield has a better one.

[Paragon]

Id take Frazier, as said before Holyfield's warrior mentality would be more of a liability than a plus. Also I believe Frazier's body punches and ripping hooks would slowly tear Holyfield down, tiring him out.

[Burning Desire]

Holyfield vs Frazier who wins ? prime of coarse. It would probably look something like Qawi vs Holyfield stylistically only Joe puts on more pressure than Qawi imo.

Dwight Muhammad Qawi wasn't a hard hitter though, he was a respectful hitter but he didn't carry that one punch type of power, where he could turn a fight around like Joe Frazier, as it shows with Dwight Muhammad Qawi only having a 47 percent KO record.

And the difference is Joe Frazier would badly shake up, Evander Holyfield unlike Dwight Muhamamd Qawi. And remember this isn't at Cruiserweight, remember Evander Holyfield was shaken up badly, by a very poor mans version of Joe Frazier aka Bert Cooper at Heavyweight.

I'll take Joe Frazier by decision, i think a prime Joe Frazier aka the 1971 version. Is a step above Dwight Muhammad Qawi, and certainly better than the 1996 version of Mike Tyson and Bert Cooper.

It would be a great fight but i see Joe Frazier's, slightly better workrate and better power being the difference here.

[mrboxer]

holyfield wins by first round knockout,frazier would not beat anyone in the top 50 today

[Dynamite Kid]

Dwight Muhammad Qawi wasn't a hard hitter though, he was a respectful hitter but he didn't carry that one punch type of power, where he could turn a fight around like Joe Frazier, as it shows with Dwight Muhammad Qawi only having a 47 percent KO record.

And the difference is Joe Frazier would bad;y shake up, Evander Holyfield unlike Dwight Muhamamd Qawi. And remember this isn't at Cruiserweight, remember Evander Holyfield was shaken up badly, by a very poor mans version of Joe Frazier aka Bert Cooper at Heavyweight.

I'll take Joe Frazier by decision, i think a prime Joe Frazier aka the 1971 version. Is a step above Dwight Muhammad Qawi, and certainly better than the 1996 version of Mike Tyson and Bert Cooper.

It would be a great fight but i see Joe Frazier's, slightly better workrate and better power being the difference here.

Agree with you.

[GJC]

holyfield wins by first round knockout,frazier would not beat anyone in the top 50 today

I'd be interested to hear the names of 50 HW's all time that could beat Frazier.
You think 50 of the current tomato cans could survive with Frazier?
Love to hear the names, I assume Chaguev will be one of them lol. Valuev, Ruiz??
Can't wait, I suggest you look at other Frazier fights other than against Foreman.

[TheGreatA]

holyfield wins by first round knockout,frazier would not beat anyone in the top 50 today

Today's top 50:

Wladimir Klitschko
Vitali Klitschko
David Haye
Nikolay Valuev
Ruslan Chagaev
Eddie Chambers
Alexander Povetkin
Juan Carlos Gomez
Samuel Peter
Tony Thompson
Chris Arreola
Oleg Maskaev
Alexander Dimitrenko
Denis Boytsov
Hasim Rahman
Ray Austin
Vladimir Virchis
Albert Sosnowski
Sam Sexton
Kevin Johnson
Fres Oquendo
Monte Barrett
Francesco Pianeta
Evander Holyfield
Chazz Witherspoon
Oleg Platov
Dominick Guinn
Manuel Quezada
Cedric Boswell
Michael Grant
James Toney
Danny Williams
Gbenga Oloukun
Odlanier Solis
Alexander Ustinov
Timur Ibragimov
Oliver McCall
Matt Skelton
Lamon Brewster
Francois Botha
Demetrice King
Taras *****ko
Lisandro Ezequiel Diaz
Derric Rossy
Tye Fields
Malik Scott
Jason Estrada
Andrew Golota
Shane Cameron
Martin Rogan

[GJC]

Today's top 50:

Wladimir Klitschko
Vitali Klitschko
David Haye
Nikolay Valuev
Ruslan Chagaev
Eddie Chambers
Alexander Povetkin
Juan Carlos Gomez
Samuel Peter
Tony Thompson
Chris Arreola
Oleg Maskaev
Alexander Dimitrenko
Denis Boytsov
Hasim Rahman
Ray Austin
Vladimir Virchis
Albert Sosnowski
Sam Sexton
Kevin Johnson
Fres Oquendo
Monte Barrett
Francesco Pianeta
Evander Holyfield
Chazz Witherspoon
Oleg Platov
Dominick Guinn
Manuel Quezada
Cedric Boswell
Michael Grant
James Toney
Danny Williams
Gbenga Oloukun
Odlanier Solis
Alexander Ustinov
Timur Ibragimov
Oliver McCall
Matt Skelton
Lamon Brewster
Francois Botha
Demetrice King
Taras *****ko
Lisandro Ezequiel Diaz
Derric Rossy
Tye Fields
Malik Scott
Jason Estrada
Andrew Golota
Shane Cameron
Martin Rogan

An abundance of riches.
Nice to see Botha in there, retire for 5 years put on 2 stone beat 3 tomato cans and ranking at 40.
What a sad state the HW division is in.
Yeah Frazier would beat some of those, he's 65 but has kept in reasonable condition.