Who was more impressive against Cotto?

Someone is about to get emotional :lol1:

Why Vargas Why Bradley 3x Why Horn only 1x (IF AT ALL) Why Rios Why Algieri Why Hatton Why Cotto* Why Broner WHYWHYWHY

Why no Mayweather-Margarito fight? Why no Mayweather-Cotto fight? Why no Mayweather-Paul Williams fight?

Manny battered him into submission, Floyd struggled and got bloodied. Cotto has already been softened up for the loss.

you are the one who tied yourself into a complete pretzel with the asterisk stuff. floyds biggest win of his career is an asterisk according to you and floyd himself. “In my mind, Miguel Cotto is still undefeated,” Mayweather said "He lost to one guy who was cheating, and to another guy at a catch weight,” No *, no Pac vs Cotto But I gave Pac credit for taking so many risks

Why no Mayweather-kostya 140 fight? Why no Mayweather-hatton 140 fight? Why no Mayweather-cotto 140 fight?

Guys, nay, LEGENDS, May was too scared to fight Shot Rios Shot Clottey Shot Broner Shot Margarito* Algieri Vargas Bradley HORN Shot Lucas May wasn't the only one. Pac stepped up to the plate. Pac is all about taking risks :boxing: you are the one who tied yourself into a complete pretzel with the asterisk stuff. floyds biggest win of his career is an asterisk according to you and floyd himself. “In my mind, Miguel Cotto is still undefeated,” Mayweather said "He lost to one guy who was cheating, and to another guy at a catch weight,”

impressive that's 6 wins vs hofers Here's 10 Pac > Barrera 2, morales 2, Marquez 2, Hatton, shot delahoya*, cotto*, shot mosley May beats them all Pac couldn't

May > Cotto, DLH, JMM, Mosley, Nelo and Pac impressive that's 6 wins vs hofers Here's 10 Pac > Barrera 2, morales 2, Marquez 2, Hatton, delahoya, cotto, mosley

May > Cotto, DLH, JMM, Mosley, Nelo and Pac

Just remember, folks Antonio margarito and Miguel cotto was #1 and #2 at 147 when floyd was there Wouldn't fight them When Kostya was #1 at 140, floyd was at 140 Didn't fight him either

i dont care about asterisks. No *, no Pac vs Cotto :wave:

Pacquiao easily.

Guys, nay, LEGENDS, May was too scared to fight Shot Rios Shot Clottey Shot Broner Shot Margarito* Algieri Vargas Bradley HORN Shot Lucas May wasn't the only one. Pac stepped up to the plate. Pac is all about taking risks :boxing:

Blahblahblah * all the way to the bank i dont care about asterisks. every fight should be debated. thats why we are here no? im saying pacs win over cotto is better than floyds cause cotto was not good above 147 and had already been beaten down twice. your argument was that he was drained ok thats fair. for example if canelo took 2 beat down losses and started fighting at cruiserweight where he never did anything. i would say floyds win over canelo is better than if someone beat him at cruiserweight. that doenst mean floyds win over canelo is great. these are two different arguments to be had. floyd himself said his win over canelo doesnt count even i dont believe that. it counts its just not great

Miguel cotto was top 10 at 140 for 3 years 2003-2005 Floyd was at 140 also for a couple a years No fight miguel cotto was top 10 at 147 from when floyd was champ til floyd retired the 1st time 2006-2008 No fight But Miguel cotto above his natural weight division, older and after several wars and beatdowns 2012 That's the best cotto :dance:

why would pac fight cotto after 2 brutal beatdowns? that was a classic floyd cherry pick pick! Why add the * ?

“In my mind, Miguel Cotto is still undefeated,” Mayweather said during their press conference in New York, as quoted by RingTV. “He lost to one guy who was cheating, and to another guy at a catch weight,” there you have it. floyds win over canelo does not count according to floyd himself!

this is a pretty strange hill for floyyd fans to die on cause the best win of his career was when he drained canelo. if you take that out...oh my his resume is slim. also hoya brought himself to 147. you are acting like pac made him go there? you know thats not true. hoya was teh a-side not pac. hoya was planning on a floyd rematch at 147. floyd pulled out and pac stepped in. pac wasnt even planning on fighting at 147 before hoya or after hoya. thats why the cotto fight was at 145. not ideal but the whole pac wants to drain people narrative is completely false and only works if you are devoid of all context. he never drained someone who was in the same division as him like floyd did Blahblahblah * all the way to the bank

The Cotto Pac would never fight. I can type that all day if you want. Yeah the cotto that was older, above his division and been thru wars and beatdowns How about the undefeated 140,147 cotto? Why didn't floyd fight him? :dance: