How can anyone seriously believe Floyd is greater than Manny P4P?

Manny Pacquiao is the greatest fighter of this era. What is greatness? Achievements Pac: 5'5, started at 105lbs, becomes 8 division champion -winner Floyd: 5'8, started at 130lbs, becomes 5 division champion Longevity Pac: Champion in his 40s, 4-decade champion -winner Floyd: Retired at 38, 3-decade champion Beginnings Pac: Started with no help/connections, malnourished, 3rd world country Floyd: Father and uncle were boxers, helped and guided him from birth Best wins at lighter weights Pac: Barrera, Morales, Ledwaba -winner Floyd: Castillo, Corrales, Manfredy Common opponents Pac: Oscar(RTD8), Hatton(KO2), Cotto(TKO12) -winner Floyd: Oscar(SD), Hatton(KO10), Cotto(UD) Unique opponents at 147+ Pac: Bradley(P4P#3), Thurman, Margarito, Clottey, Vargas -winner Floyd: Maidana(Not P4P), Kidnelo (23yo), Guerrero, Berto, Ortiz Marquez facts Floyd: Missed weight, dragged Marquez up 2-3 weight classes Pac: Fought Marquez 4 times, only 1 loss to Memo-trained Roidquez Their fight? Floyd: Caught using illegal IV Pac: Denied pain-killer shot for injured shoulder Remember this: Floyd is naturally 2 weight classes bigger than Pac, yet couldn't even stop Pac lol. Imagine if Pac was naturally 2 weight classes bigger than Floyd? Floyd would be destroyed! We are talking Pound-for-Pound here!!!! Most importantly: Pac: I fight to make the people happy Floyd: Fans don't pay my bills, I'm a rich coward How can any true boxing fan believe Floyd is greater than Pacquiao, when Pacquiao is naturally smaller yet accomplished more? Pound-for-pound, Manny Pacquiao will always be above Floyd Mayweather Jr, now and forever.

Comments (20)

pasawayako

floyd fans says "floyd is greater than pac" boxing trainer, boxing legends, boxers, referee, analyst all says "pac is greater than floyd" see the difference?????

5y ago

AJs_Boy

No reputable source ranks Pac over Floyd....because he isn't. It's not even debatable. Especially since they fought and Floyd won clearly. Clown thread by a clown poster. Deal with it. You're too dumb to read with your 4th grade education :spankme:

5y ago

SkillspayBills

No reputable source ranks Pac over Floyd....because he isn't. It's not even debatable. Especially since they fought and Floyd won clearly. Clown thread by a clown poster. Deal with it.

5y ago

Truth_Bringer

If there's a poll worldwide on who's the greater boxer it would be a total landslide in favor of pac. Yes and most thought Pac beat Floyd too

5y ago

pasawayako

If there's a poll worldwide on who's the greater boxer it would be a total landslide in favor of pac.

5y ago

pasawayako

You and I both know Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that. I just find it hilarious that you want to pass off Kellermans opinion as expert when you swear that Manny beat Floyd but Kellerman doesn't agree. Basically you want us to accept Kellermans opinion when it supports your agenda but not when it doesn't. On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life. No you're the only one believed that floyd beat pac. Lol. So u only want to believed max kellerman if it suits your agenda? :lol1: Boxing legends, boxing trainers and analyst think that pac is greater than floyd while floyd fans think that floyd is greater than pac. :lol1:

5y ago

TJ_highway

Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses. What's your point? The greatest of champions is not measured by losses. But how they transcend their losses and continue fighting. Sugar Ray Robinson had a total of 200 fights 109 KO's. How many KO's did Froid have? He had 27 KO's, minus MMA guy non boxer and that cheap shot to Victor Ortiz in 2011. The TKO prior to that was Ricky Hatton in 2007.

5y ago

just_the_facts

Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses. What's your point? The greatest of champions is not measured by losses. But how they transcend their losses and continue fighting. So losses count for nothing?

5y ago

RGJTMMRDCMJRJSM

Figure in the 7 losses, one of them H2H. Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses. What's your point? The greatest of champions is not measured by losses. But how they transcend their losses and continue fighting.

5y ago

just_the_facts

How accomplished the fighters Pac & Floyd beat (on paper) at the time they fought them by number of world title scalps on their opponents resume: Pac: Dela Hoya - 24 Morales II and III - 17, 17 Barrera I and II - 16, 21 Mosley - 15 Cotto - 9 Margarito - 10 Bradley II and III - 9, 11 Larios - 8 Marquez II and III - 6, 9 Ledwaba - 6 Broner - 6 Thurman - 3 Hatton - 3 Sasakul - 3 Julio - 3 Diaz - 1 Clottey - 1 Algieri - 1 Vargas - 1 Floyd: Dela Hoya - 24 Pacquiao - 15 Mosley - 15 Cotto - 11 Judah - 9 Marquez - 7 Canelo - 7 Berto - 7 Gatti - 6 Guerrero - 5 Hernandez - 4 Corrales - 4 Castillo I and II - 3, 3 Hatton - 3 Corley - 3 Maidana I and II - 2, 2 Baldomir - 2 Vargas - 1 Mitchell - 1 Ortiz - 1 Pac > Floyd Figure in the 7 losses, one of them H2H.

5y ago

just_the_facts

So u think max kellerman is wrong? So u think pac won the fight? Which one is it? :lol1: You and I both know Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that. I just find it hilarious that you want to pass off Kellermans opinion as expert when you swear that Manny beat Floyd but Kellerman doesn't agree. Basically you want us to accept Kellermans opinion when it supports your agenda but not when it doesn't. On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life.

5y ago

RGJTMMRDCMJRJSM

5y ago

pasawayako

This the difference. Floyd fans said that floyd is greater than pac. On the other side Boxing legends, trainers, analyst said that pac is greater than floyd.

5y ago

pasawayako

The same Max Kellerman who scored Floyd/Pac wide for Floyd? Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that. On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life. So u think max kellerman is wrong? So u think pac won the fight? Which one is it? :lol1:

5y ago

just_the_facts

Both great fighters. Floyd is considered by everyone to be the BEST fighter of his era. Some consider Manny to be the GREATEST. Others say its Floyd. I think Floyd is greater but there are arguments for both sides. I guess we will have to see when it is all said and done where history falls down. Level headed, intelligent comments in a Floyd/Pac thread? Where's the fun in that? Just kidding. Totally agree, good post.

5y ago

Kagami_Taiga

5y ago

just_the_facts

Floyd fans know very little about boxing- max kellerman And it show why they even think that floyd is greater than pac. :lol1: The same Max Kellerman who scored Floyd/Pac wide for Floyd? Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that. On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life.

5y ago

pasawayako

The same Max Kellerman who scored Floyd/Manny wide for Floyd? Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that. May 2nd of 2015 Floyd ruined your life. Yeah he scored for floyd and? Max said pac is much greater than floyd and it's not even close. Max is correct fot saying that floyd fans know very very little about boxing that's why its understandable that they think floyd is greater than pac.

5y ago

pasawayako

No he wouldn't because he's intelligent enough to know all time ratings are subjective and many people in boxing disagree with him. He would however laugh at dumb casual fan boys like you for swinging on Pacquiao's nuts for over a decade. Floyd fans know very little about boxing- max kellerman And it show why they even think that floyd is greater than pac. :lol1:

5y ago

PRINCEKOOL

The conclusion for me of this thread is? Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather are levels above the top elite fighters of today 'But Mayweather was just that much better than Pacquiao overall' Floyd Mayweather is the better fighter, within amateur boxing gyms all over the world 'It is Mayweather's ability that will be aspired to etc'. Anthony Joshua does not sit around studying Manny Pacquiao, he looks to fighters such as Mayweather 'For inspiration to improve his tradesman skills'.

5y ago