Who ranks higher on your ATG list? Kell Brook or Amir Khan

Gotta go with Khan on this one. He really would've been something special if he wasn't so chinny. Edit: I answered the question as in who had the better career. If these guys are on your ATG list, I at least hope that your list is very deep. Unless you are talking about all time great British fighters, in which I would still have both quite far down the list. Amir Khan is not British. Get your facts right ****ing idiot. Neither are guys like Lennox Lewis, Chris Eubank, Nigel Benn, Anthony Joshua, Frank Bruno, Naseem Hamed and Kal Yafai. Nor will they ever be.

U lost me at ATG. Brook the better fighter but worst career Basically this. Between beating a bunch of second tier fighters and getting injured tru-out his career Brook falls short. Khan has the better career but neither is ATG.

Gotta go with Khan on this one. He really would've been something special if he wasn't so chinny. Edit: I answered the question as in who had the better career. If these guys are on your ATG list, I at least hope that your list is very deep. Unless you are talking about all time great British fighters, in which I would still have both quite far down the list.

U lost me at ATG. Brook the better fighter but worst career

Brook easily.

Who do you rate higher on your ATG list? I mean technically, neither of these guys would actually be on my ATG list, but.... yeah as far as who had the better career - I think it's Amir Kahn. It's interesting, they are both disappointments (with all respect) to some degree and are forever connected...

Will they even become part of an ATG discussion, let alone ATG list??? HOF is even a difficult discussion for them

Neither get near an ATG list, but Khan is far greater than Brook. Better resume, wins, accomplishments etc.

I think Brook's the better fighter and I'd pick him to win if they'd fought at any point in their careers, but Amir achieved more.

It's Khan, but could have been Brook if he made better decisions.

I prefer Brook, but it's clearly Khan. Beat way better opposition.

Khan is the GOAT for a reason. Brook shouldn’t even be mentioned in the same sentence with him.