Who ranks higher on your ATG list? Marco Antonio Barrera or Erik Morales?

Morales cause he beat the pacman and barrera didnt

I'd say Barrera . I think he beat erik 2 outta 3 and a win against hamed will be legendary . though erik had a pac win . barrera couldve beaten marquez also . - -BALCO Juan ducked prime MAB and Morales and a couple of Manny rematches. Ducked the past prime Morales too.

Ya but he could of won . It was a good fight, wish we woulda got morales vs marquez also

Barrera lost to marquez... Ya but he could of won .

I'd say Barrera . I think he beat erik 2 outta 3 and a win against hamed will be legendary . though erik had a pac win . barrera couldve beaten marquez also . Barrera lost to marquez... the cards were too wide and the kd round should have been even due to barrera fouling marquez but I still thought marquez won (much closer than the scorecards suggest cause of the kd not counting and the point deduction)

I'd say Barrera . I think he beat erik 2 outta 3 and a win against hamed will be legendary . though erik had a pac win . barrera couldve beaten marquez also .

I've always favored morales.. and then when he came back and had that thriller with garcia and maidana It kinda solidified it for me

I’d call it even.

Flip a coin

Morales and it isn't even close. I'm offended by the question TBH.

My instincts tell me barrera without delving too deeply. But morales has win over pac. So a win over pac isn't a lottery ticket to greatnes . To become as great as pac, you got to do what pac s did, rather than beat pac

- -Morales always the face first plodder, el burro, whereas Barrera could fight and box with intelligence, el matador.

I started this "who ranks higher on your ATG list" and now everyone is suddenly making these threads like hotcakes. :lol1::lol1: no you didn't

At their peak respective talents, I think Morales was simply a better fighter, but Marco altered his style and became more of a beautiful boxer, which extended his career, and gave him more longevity at the top than Erik. On an ATG list, I'd have to put MAB slightly higher.