Are Manny and Floyd both locked in as Top 10 ATGs?

Now that both men's careers are basically over, let's take a look at just some of their unique accomplishments. Manny "Pac-Man" Pacquiao Champion in more divisions than anyone in history (8 divisions) Beat longevity in boxing history (champion in 4 decades) First man to become lineal champion in 5 weight classes Only 4-time welterweight champion in history Oldest welterweight champion in history Floyd "Money" Mayweather Beat more World Champions than anyone in history Beat more Future Hall-of-Famers than anyone in history Best defense ever (Compubox) Most accurate puncher ever (Compubox) Undefeated as a Professional (50-0) Just two truly incredible athletes, both men set records that may never be broken. Have they done enough in your eyes to be in the Top 10 of all time? If yes, where in the Top 10 do you rank each? If not, list 10 boxers who are greater. {"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/metro.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2017\/06\/455405618.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&zoom=1&resize=644%2C449&ssl=1"} {"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"https:\/\/www.thesun.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/07\/NINTCHDBPICT000420531789.jpg"}

Comments (20)

blowblow

Until you can name names, don't ask me shlt :) hey your boy idolized pacman. can you defend that? seeing him jumping off his seat when he k.o morales and k.d thurman? definitely floyd is a pacman's fanboy

5y ago

BodyBagz

So you think your idol is correct for saying numbers don't lie? Until you can name names, don't ask me shlt :)

5y ago

Bipolar_Hero

Yes they are.

5y ago

The_Big_Dunn

I don’t have either in my top 10 ATG. IMO, Floyd is somewhere between 12-20 and Manny somewhere around 30-35.

5y ago

pasawayako

He claimed not to be a fanboy and went on to disprove that :lol1: So you think your idol is correct for saying numbers don't lie?

5y ago

BodyBagz

Remember as what your idol said that men lie women lie but numbers don't lie. He claimed not to be a fanboy and went on to disprove that :lol1:

5y ago

hugh_grant

How could they not both go down as atgs? They basically fought every one and anyone and their fight was 50/50 stalemate and extremely competitive. You can give the edge to either, but you can't deny that both are great! Pac is higher though as Floyd there are more unanswered questions. Not fighting abroad, no rematches, how does he come back from loss. He did avenge losses to Castillo and maidana but thing is people want to know how Floyd would have faired in 2 nd fight if the first fight wins weren't given to him but to Castillo and maidana instead like they should have been.. Pac is top 10. 100 years from now, Pac’s achievements will still be relevant while Floyd’s money, choice of opponents(Berto, McGregor, Victor Ortiz, Guerrero) and diva antics will be his legacy Pac will be remembered more just like he is now. When.Pac beat thurman, you couldn't aim enough superlatives at pac.

5y ago

pasawayako

Obviously not a Pac fanboy :lol1: Remember as what your idol said that men lie women lie but numbers don't lie.

5y ago

BodyBagz

Manny yes Floyd nope!!!!! Obviously not a Pac fanboy :lol1:

5y ago

BodyBagz

One of mayweather’s wins comes from fighting McGregor...shouldn’t count. Everyone knows that fight was a money grabbing scheme of a fight. McGregor had no chance of winning SRR fought 3 guys who were 0-0;0, IN A ROW.

5y ago

blowblow

Meh..... Vargas, Rios, Lucas, Broner, Clottey, Margarito, HORN, Algieri, Bradley 3x..... And not one Pac fan has a thing to say :lol1: im laughing so hard now.. see how you put me into ignored in your thread coz i'd finally shut your mf up. real talk.. floyd is pacman's fanboy.. how can you defend that? by avoiding me? you lose bro.. such a mf loser

5y ago

pasawayako

Floyd requested and received permission from the athletic commission dumb aszz. Bert Sugar NEVER said Pac was the GOAT and that makes you a LIAR. Yes he requested 2 weeks after the fight. :lol1:

5y ago

BodyBagz

It's not so much me being defensive -- it's more just really me pointing out how absurd and laughable it is to say that Pacquiao was: A) An "afterthought" and B) An international superstar and 2nd highest grossing PPV fighter of all-time only because he was a humble Pinoy with a fan friendly style :lol1: I have no problem at all with you having Floyd ahead of him, but those two statements are just...they're comical. Anyway that's all I have to say on it, I gotta get to bed because I have to get up super early tomorrow. Have a nice night dude. :chomp: By the way Body Bagz I still love you bro :beerchug: :beerchug: Squabbles never hurt anyone

5y ago

just_the_facts

It's not lies floyd hired usada to make sure that he was given a pass to use illegal amount of IV and it was documented that he use 12xmore than the allowed limit. Now who's lying? :lol1: Floyd requested and received permission from the athletic commission dumb aszz. Bert Sugar NEVER said Pac was the GOAT and that makes you a LIAR.

5y ago

Mike_D

By the way Body Bagz I still love you bro :beerchug:

5y ago

Mike_D

Look, you Pac fans see him through loving eyes. Especially when the other guy is May (loudmouth wife beater. Mean guy who made Pac take random blood tests). And why do Pac fans get so damned defensive ? As if reading criticisms on him is a crime. It's not so much me being defensive -- it's more just really me pointing out how absurd and laughable it is to say that Pacquiao was: A) An "afterthought" and B) An international superstar and 2nd highest grossing PPV fighter of all-time only because he was a humble Pinoy with a fan friendly style :lol1: I have no problem at all with you having Floyd ahead of him, but those two statements are just...they're comical. Anyway that's all I have to say on it, I gotta get to bed because I have to get up super early tomorrow. Have a nice night dude. :chomp:

5y ago

blowblow

Meh..... Vargas, Rios, Lucas, Broner, Clottey, Margarito, HORN, Algieri, Bradley 3x..... And not one Pac fan has a thing to say :lol1: oh i forgot.. your boy can also fight Jorge Kahwagi.. he is getting more and more funnier.

5y ago

BodyBagz

but wait there's more.... there's more clown left to fight.. -your boy. Meh..... Vargas, Rios, Lucas, Broner, Clottey, Margarito, HORN, Algieri, Bradley 3x..... And not one Pac fan has a thing to say :lol1:

5y ago

blowblow

People retire when they accomplish everything. Some guys stick around and compile. but wait there's more.... there's more clown left to fight.. -your boy.

5y ago

BodyBagz

or should he go back to wwe for much entertaning fight.. thats epic. ive never seen so called ATG this low. People retire when they accomplish everything. Some guys stick around and compile.

5y ago