Got this idea from Grandpa Bernard aka Leon but made it a little more focused on particular fights rather entire resume.
So using the same timeline when Pacquiao fought them, if you put Marquez in there at that point in time, how would he have done.
What is your take on it:
Diaz:
De La Hoya:
Hatton:
Cotto:
Clottey:
Margarito:
Mosley:
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley:
Rios:
Algieri:
Mayweather:
Vargas:
Horn:
Matthysse:
Broner:
Thurman:
I'll post mines and would ask if folks could answer with the similar template of winner/how
What is your take on it:
Diaz:JMM WIN
De La Hoya:JMM WIN
Hatton:JMM WIN
Cotto:COTTO WIN
Clottey:JMM WIN
Margarito:JMM WIN
Mosley:JMM WIN
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley:BRADLEY WIN
Rios:JMM WIN
Algieri:JMM WIN
Mayweather:MAYWEATHER WIN
NO NEED TO DISCUSS THE REST HE WAS OLD AS HELL AND COULDNT EVEN GET THRU TRAINING CAMP
But Larry you did the same thing that other poster did and just gave the winner but not by how. So u put jmm wins over de la Hoya, but how ko? UD? Sd? If decision, how could jmm get a decision over someone of de la Hoya calibur when he couldn't even get a decision from someone like Chris John? same with hatton.
So Marquez beats 160+ pounders clottey and margarito even though he doesn't have the fire power or foot work?(u think that fat slow Marquez who fought at 147 could beat these pretty much middleweights?). He beats clottey but loses to cotto whom some gave clottey beating cotto?
So "no need to go through the rest" means he takes the L
So by your take, Marquez goes 8-8
If someone like Larry can answer this while others can't, I got no idea about these posters here now
What is your take on it:
Diaz:JMM WIN
De La Hoya:JMM WIN
Hatton:JMM WIN
Cotto:COTTO WIN
Clottey:JMM WIN
Margarito:JMM WIN
Mosley:JMM WIN
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley:BRADLEY WIN
Rios:JMM WIN
Algieri:JMM WIN
Mayweather:MAYWEATHER WIN
NO NEED TO DISCUSS THE REST HE WAS OLD AS HELL AND COULDNT EVEN GET THRU TRAINING CAMP
What it your take on it:
Diaz: JMM
De La Hoya: at 147 (like Manny had) JMM
Hatton: JMM
Cotto: Cotto
Clottey: Clottey
Margarito: JMM
Mosley: In 2011...JMM
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley: Bradley
Rios: JMM
Algieri: JMM
Mayweather: Floyd
Vargas: JMM
Horn: JMM
Matthysse: JMM
Broner: close fight
Thurman: JMM
thanks for the attempt
you know how those victories would be? ud/ko/etc
so you think jmm, who could barely move cuz of his bad knees, would've beaten thurman huh, cool
What it your take on it:
Diaz: JMM
De La Hoya: at 147 (like Manny had) JMM
Hatton: JMM
Cotto: Cotto
Clottey: Clottey
Margarito: JMM
Mosley: In 2011...JMM
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley: Bradley
Rios: JMM
Algieri: JMM
Mayweather: Floyd
Vargas: JMM
Horn: JMM
Matthysse: JMM
Broner: close fight
Thurman: JMM
lol everybody don't want to do this cuz they don't want to give marquez a losing record.
a lot of people stroke marquez as one of these all time greats yet they can't even say how he'd fare against these opponents
surely if he was as great as people make him, he'd do fairly well
why can't anyone contribute? thought this was a boxing forum to talk boxing?
no over thinking, just take marquez and put him in those scheduled fights in those times. After losing the 2nd fight to Pacquiao, instead of fighting casamayor, juan diaz, he went on to fight david diaz, de la hoya, hatton, etc
seeing no responses continues to show proof folks here don't want to talk boxing no more
or they know how bad marquez really was and only looked good cuz he jacked off to pacquiao and had a mental health obsession on it
Got this idea from Grandpa Bernard aka Leon but made it a little more focused on particular fights rather entire resume.
So using the same timeline when Pacquiao fought them, if you put Marquez in there at that point in time, how would he have done.
What it your take on it:
Diaz:
De La Hoya:
Hatton:
Cotto:
Clottey:
Margarito:
Mosley:
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley:
Rios:
Algieri:
Mayweather:
Vargas:
Horn:
Matthysse:
Broner:
Thurman:
I'll post mines and would ask if folks could answer with the similar template of winner/how
You do realize JMM is 5.5 years older than Pacquiao right? So I’m not sure if you really mean your putting JMM in the exact same circumstances as Pac: Age, Aside, Catchweights etc. If you did I think JMM would be undefeated and we’ll never know how good he would have done vs Floyd
Here's mine:
Diaz: Marquez UD
De La Hoya: De La Hoya UD (Marquez cries robbery)
Hatton: Hatton SD(Marquez cries robbery)
Cotto: Cotto KO (Marquez cries he's too small)
Clottey: Clottey KO (Marquez cries Clottey too big)
Margarito: Margarito KO (Marquez cries Margarito too big)
Mosley: Marquez SD
(by this time Marquez hooks up with known steroid cheat Memo)
Bradley: Bradley UD (Marquez cries robbery)
Rios: Marquez UD
Algieri: Algieri SD (Marquez cries robbery)
Mayweather: Mayweather UD
Vargas: Vargas SD (Marquez cries robbery)
Horn: Horn UD (Marquez cries robbery)
Matthysse: Marquez UD
Broner: Broner UD (Marquez even older at this point and cries robbery)
Thurman: Thurman KO
Of those 16 fights at those times:
Marquez goes 4 Wins, 12 losses