Who did better against Floyd? Pacquiao or Maidana in the first fight?

Manny fought clean. If Maidana fights clean he would’ve gotten washed. I can’t believe people give him credit for that trash.

This is not even something I have to think about or consider. Floyd vs Maidana 1 was close. Floyd vs Manny Pacquiao was not close.

Maidana clearly

The Maidana that fought May would have won/robbed at least 1 of the 2 fights vs Pac I would have loved to see that Maidana vs Pacquiao.

I remember Maidana being manhandled by past it overweight Morales. It was definitely time for Floyd to cashout

even Guerrero did better than Pacquiao. this thread should ask who did better Oscar, Maidana or Cotto instead. You bugging lol. Guerrero didnt do sh#t...

The Maidana fights were exciting. Maidana took chances and pushed forward. The Pac fight was a typical Floyd fight. Good for the first three rounds and then a boring schooling.

OP must’ve been jerking off while watching poll results and reading posts in this thread

But if both fights were fought in the losers own country we know Floyd would have 2 losses on record.

Damn, McGregor too? I had McGregor winning 5 rounds from Floyd after thinking he wouldn't win a minute of any round seeing as how this was his first pro fight. Manny was injured so it is what it is

Maidana, he whooped Mayweather's ass and won de facto but the boxing establishment needed that MayPac Cash, so they gave the W to Mayweather.

El Chino pulled a JLC while Pacquiao was utter $h1t like Berto

All I can think of when I read this is the Captain Obvious guy saying something stupid.... The poll does seem very one-sided so far, with Pacquiao getting trounced.

Floyd fight scared to a one-arm, shorter PAC. Im just being Honest :D

Be honest. All I can think of when I read this is the Captain Obvious guy saying something stupid....

Damn, McGregor too? Dare I say it....Conor Mcnuggets in his boxing debut did a better job then Manny Pacquiao

Maidana did far better. Fight should have been a draw, Floyd did not beat him in the first fight. Yep. Huge Floyd fan, fan of maidana too. I woulda been fine with a draw in the first maidana fight. My brother watched it without sound ( he likes to do that sometimes ) and he thought Floyd won. But I know in a close round, it can look like a win for the underdog and a loss for the favourite. Maidana over preformed and Manny underperformed in a way. I should watch both fights again. But I do remember telling my gf that floyd might have just lost vs maidana.

Be honest. I take back my Poll choice. I just saw a Connor Manny one just like this...Maidana did better . because he didnt have a torn shoulder injury though.

Maidana cotton and McGregor all did better then manny. Damn, McGregor too?

Maidana cotton and McGregor all did better then manny.