With each great win Pacquiao accomplishes in his older age, and with each new challenge Canelo conquers, it’s making Mayweather look more and more like one of the top All-Time Greats.
Thoughts?
He also lost to Castillo so Floyd just put Castillo in the Hall of fame since Floyd’s greatnesses puts Castillo as Mexico’s best boxer since he man handled TBE
Oh yeah, I forgot about the Castillo fight, good on you on.
Floyd lost to Castillo, Maidana and he should of got a DQ in the Judah fight because of Roger Mayweather's antics.
great point.
Can't deny facts that Floyd resume has live bodies as opposed to Manny.
If you compare HOF fighters on both resumes and what they were able to accomplish- Its Floyd all day.
Not saying Manny didn't have ATG opponents - just that Manny lost at least once to all to all but one.
Okay, okay!!
Sorry, I didn’t mean for this to get so nasty..
Seriously, I just think those wins look good on Mayweather’s record, but I get the different points some of you have made.
For the record, I don’t think Mayweather is the best of all time, but I do think he’s an all-time great, probably top 20 or so.
But fair points were made here, and I can see some ways in which my logic may have harbored some fallacies...
:rofl: Man. First rule of NSB. You bring up Floyd or Pac and you're gonna get a tornado of bullchit no matter how neutral you try to make that ish. The kids on here just can't seem to let that crap go.
Okay, okay!!
Sorry, I didn’t mean for this to get so nasty..
Seriously, I just think those wins look good on Mayweather’s record, but I get the different points some of you have made.
For the record, I don’t think Mayweather is the best of all time, but I do think he’s an all-time great, probably top 20 or so.
But fair points were made here, and I can see some ways in which my logic may have harbored some fallacies...
Lil Floyd don’t credit for none of Pac's and Nelo's accomplishments or victories!! He beat both dudes in typical Lil Floyd fashion...Clear UD...and that’s the only thing he gets credit for when it comes to Nelo and Pac...stop trying to boost that little mfs position on the charts...Lil Floyd is a rich sucker who knows how to win rounds without taking punishment...that’s a good thing and he’s probably the best at that!! Nothing else!!
Whoa where you been pat'na? Lol
Mayweather could have added to his own legacy instead of fighting berto, mcnugget and a fw kick boxer. Floyd doesn’t get props just cuz pac is still choosing to behave like a fighter.
With each great win Pacquiao accomplishes in his older age, and with each new challenge Canelo conquers, it’s making Mayweather look more and more like one of the top All-Time Greats.
Thoughts?
- -Tenshin and TUEs his current level.
What grade you in?
Each victory gets better over time because both opponents keep beating elites
Floyd 1st man to beat two different fighter of the decade
Apart from nel o weren't elite when Floyd beat nel o with cw.? And Pac wasn't far removed from jmm ko, still tentative and gunshy. Context puts things into perspective.
First to beat 2 different fighters of decade? Yet Floyd himself wasn't ever a fotd, let alone best of era and all time.
Lil Floyd don’t credit for none of Pac's and Nelo's accomplishments or victories!! He beat both dudes in typical Lil Floyd fashion...Clear UD...and that’s the only thing he gets credit for when it comes to Nelo and Pac...stop trying to boost that little mfs position on the charts...Lil Floyd is a rich sucker who knows how to win rounds without taking punishment...that’s a good thing and he’s probably the best at that!! Nothing else!!
Floyd has a weak resume of beating people not as dominant as Pac did. So flouds fans will try live off of Pac s and nelos achievements?.
Does Oliver McCall fans or Rahman fans try live off lennox lewis wins? How can what Pac and nel o do add to clouds legacy? Does bh wins add to rjj legacy? Did cott o beating Sergio mean Pac beats Sergio and might as well put Sergio on Pac s boxrec or wiki page?
So Mannys multiple CW are good against guys beaten before and after and Floyds one is no good against an undefeated guy that still hasnt lost again.
It appears very easy for you to be an imbecile troll but I dont think its an act, I fully believe you are not very intelligent.
Floyd has a weak resume of beating people not as dominant as Pac did. So flouds fans will try live off of Pac s and nelos achievements?.
Does Oliver McCall fans or Rahman fans try live off lennox lewis wins? How can what Pac and nel o do add to clouds legacy? Does bh wins add to rjj legacy? Did cott o beating Sergio mean Pac beats Sergio and might as well put Sergio on Pac s boxrec or wiki page?
no, because floyd never beat canelo/pac in the fashion that canelo/pac is beating their opponents. so going by your logic, pac is also adding torrecampo's legacy? lol!!!
Floyd beat them BOTH :dunce:
Nah, every win nel o has now onwards adds to his legacy alone. So by end of nelo career, his resume will be either seen as inferior or superior. Floyd s win was a cw win. The win means little in big scheme of things. It s only baring and relevance is it helped Floyd keep unbeaten record
Oh lord.... Then that should apply to Saildo then...And Margirto should get ATG credit from beating Martinez?
Whats the guys name that KOed Manny and B-Hop?
This is casual logic 101
Applying this to Canelo is even more nonsense due to the fact he moved up like 4 divisions afterwards
Canelo is one of Floyds best wins.
Canelo came away from that loss learning the sweet science of picking the right time to fight guys when the resistance is at its very least, and seems to be applying it properly.
I guess you can throw Floyd a couple of points for having a win on Manny after Manny beating Thurman, but it isn't what it could have been had be beaten the far more prime Manny of 2009. Plus Manny claimed he had a bum shoulder that night.
How about when Pac gets knocked out cold???? Does that count against Mayweather? You can't have it both ways.
Yes it absolutely does and nobody has ever said it wouldnt. If manny has been on a losing streak after floyd then it would show that he was way past it. But he isn't remember? He just beat a "young undefeated lion in his prime" remember?
Anyone who says Floyd’s win over canelo isn’t shat is a full blown moron, he took that boy to school. As far as the pac sparring match I wasn’t too impressed.