You actually think Hurd is a better boxer than Lomachenko and Crawford? Or is it because they are Top Rank guys?
I like Hurd a lot but just seems off.
I determine "pound for pound" ratings based on who is dominating their division the most. The five fighters I listed have accomplished far more in their weight divisions than Crawford or Lomachenko have in theirs.
Usyk hold every recognized world title in his division. That is far more impressive than anything Crawford has done at his weight. All Crawford has done is beaten a weak champion for the most lightly regarded major title.
I know many choose to determine P4P ratings by taking into account accomplishments in various weight classes over the years, but I personally just look at the champions of the 17 divisions and judge who is doing the most in their weight class compared to others in other divisions.
#1 - Oleksandr Usyk
#2 - Anthony Joshua
#3 - Mikey Garcia
#4 - Gennady Golovkin
#5 - Jarrett Hurd
You actually think Hurd is a better boxer than Lomachenko and Crawford? Or is it because they are Top Rank guys?
I like Hurd a lot but just seems off.
It's in my sig
My Top 10 Right Now:7/24/2018
1. Terence "Bud" Crawford
2. Vasyl "Hi Tech" Lomachenko
3. Srisiket Sor Rungvisai
4. Miguel "Mikey" Garcia
5. Gennady "GGG" Golovkin
1. Usyk (becoming undisputed traveling to multiple opponents backyards.)
2. Canelo/GGG winner (hopefully its decisive)
3. Lomachenko (whooped Rigo's ass)
4. Crawford (undisputed at 140 and the only guy I see whoopin Spence at 147.)
5. Kovalev (still the best at 175. nobody is as good as Ward, doubt he'll lose again.)
6. Mikey (keep yo ass away from Spence.)
7. Spence (Porter, Danny and Thurman all hoes.)
8. Wilder (Eddie Sperm worst nightmare.)
9. Pacquiao (old as dirt but I'll pick him over anybody not named Crawford or Spence.)
10. Gassiev (he'll dominate CW division with no Usyk in it.)
up next: Benavidez at 168 (he'll wipe the division out.)
1. Bud-Without question the best fighter in the world.
2. GG-Could temporarily replace Bud as pfp best with ko or clean win.
3. Canelo-Same comments as GG.
4. Garcia-A skill or two less than Bud
5. Lomachenko-Rose quickly fighting tough comp.