If Crawford, Thurman, and Spence we're natural HW how would they fair?

I know fans like to think like that, but it's so silly because if GGG was 250 pounds, he wouldn't be the same fighter at all. It's like saying who would win between a fish and a cow if the fish was actually a cow instead of a fish. The fish obviously, because if it was a cow it would be able to breathe under water and swim, the cow would simply get out-classed by the 'fish-cow'. The 'fish-cow' could essentially do everything the cow can do whilst also having some of the more advantageous traits of a fish.

But if everything was equal, who would win? GGG would probably a more rugged Klits or Provetkin I know fans like to think like that, but it's so silly because if GGG was 250 pounds, he wouldn't be the same fighter at all. It's like saying who would win between a fish and a cow if the fish was actually a cow instead of a fish.

I have no problem with judging fighters based on how well they're performing in their weight class to determine who has been the most successful for their size. Anthony Joshua would obviously destroy GGG, but "pound for pound" I would rate GGG higher because he has accomplished more at middleweight than Joshua has accomplished at heavyweight. GGG has unified more belts, made more defenses, proven himself more clearly as the #1 in his division, etc. But if everything was equal, who would win? GGG would probably a more rugged Klits or Provetkin

So P4p is basically bull**** I have no problem with judging fighters based on how well they're performing in their weight class to determine who has been the most successful for their size. Anthony Joshua would obviously destroy GGG, but "pound for pound" I would rate GGG higher because he has accomplished more at middleweight than Joshua has accomplished at heavyweight. GGG has unified more belts, made more defenses, proven himself more clearly as the #1 in his division, etc.

You only think that because of the attributes you've seen them display, attributes they only have because of their smaller size. So P4p is basically bull****

You only think that because of the attributes you've seen them display, attributes they only have because of their smaller size. PROVE it then big guy

Thurman would be a more athletic David Haye Crawford would be a more fundamental Deontay Wilder And Spence would be Anthony Joshua with more leverage. You only think that because of the attributes you've seen them display, attributes they only have because of their smaller size.

That's sexist and misogynist It's also true

if they were heavyweights, they wouldn't have the speed and finesse that makes you think they're great to begin with. it's like saying what if a horse was an olympic runner. well if they were an olympic runner, they wouldnt have the attributes of a horse anymore. Thurman would be a more athletic David Haye Crawford would be a more fundamental Deontay Wilder And Spence would be Anthony Joshua with more leverage.

Thurman would still be an inactive b1tch spence would have even bigger nipples and Crawford wouldnt look like a ethiopian That's sexist and misogynist

if they were heavyweights, they wouldn't have the speed and finesse that makes you think they're great to begin with. it's like saying what if a horse was an olympic runner. well if they were an olympic runner, they wouldnt have the attributes of a horse anymore.What you say is true. I think Spence is better for a welterweight than any of the current best heavyweights are for heavyweights.

Thurman would still be an inactive b1tch spence would have even bigger nipples and Crawford wouldnt look like a ethiopian

They would be the best heavyweights. Welterweight is a stronger weight class now than heavyweights in my opinion.

I think these three would be the best three heavyweights if they were natural heavyweights. Discuss? if they were heavyweights, they wouldn't have the speed and finesse that makes you think they're great to begin with. it's like saying what if a horse was an olympic runner. well if they were an olympic runner, they wouldnt have the attributes of a horse anymore.

Imagine if Sonny Liston had been a cruiserweight. Best cruiserweight ever!

"If Crawford, Thurman, and Spence we're natural HW how would they fair?" *were *fare Sorry, damn auto input

"If Crawford, Thurman, and Spence we're natural HW how would they fair?" *were *fare

Bud would ko both.

Slow day in the world of boxing, I suppose