Imo tiger is waaaaay past prime at 17/18, but he still has enough in the tank to destroy all the top heavyweights. I think he racked up 1 fight a month in his early teens so he should be able to take out the top 10 in a year.
I think AJ wins because I never heard of Tiger Muhammed. If you you are talking about Muhammad Ali in his prime I think Ali would beat AJ.
What? You haven't heard of Tiger Mohammed?
And you call yourself a boxing(scene) fan?
Educate yourself
https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=576065
;)
After toying with him for a couple minutes to entertain the crowd, Tiger Muhammad backs AJ into a corner and unloads a twenty-one punch combination that crumbles him to a heap and leaves him motionless on the canvas.