Óscar De la Hoya vs. Sergio Martínez | 154 lb | Who would have won?

I think it's close but I picked Martinez. Oscar was at his best as a welterweight and was a bit past his best when he moved up to 154. Martinez was very lean and hard at 154. He was a naturally bigger boxer than Oscar and he fought the best fights of his career at 154 and still fought very well in his early days as middleweight champ.At 154 Martinez was faster and punched harder than Oscar did at that weight. Don't get me wrong. I think it's close and Oscar could box well and punch hard at 154. Martinez was just a little bigger and faster than Oscar at 154. Mosley beat Oscar twice at 154 and Martinez was better at 154 than Mosley or Oscar. He wasn't much better than them. He was just enough better to win. You dont give Mosley enough credit,he is beast in 140 to 154 no differance in his good days,and Oscar could won it it was controversial decision,If Martinez act ****y like in pavlik fight Oscar hook ice him,Oscar carried power and speed very well and is better fighter overall from Footwork/Creating angles to offensiv skill and defense,allso had Iron chin,i think he ice Sergio in 6-12rounds

Oscar was mutch better fighter,Sergio was stopped in 154 by Margo i belive,Sergio cant fight oscar in Pavlik style,Oscar by murder with left hooks.

I think it's close but I picked Martinez. Oscar was at his best as a welterweight and was a bit past his best when he moved up to 154. Martinez was very lean and hard at 154. He was a naturally bigger boxer than Oscar and he fought the best fights of his career at 154 and still fought very well in his early days as middleweight champ.At 154 Martinez was faster and punched harder than Oscar did at that weight. Don't get me wrong. I think it's close and Oscar could box well and punch hard at 154. Martinez was just a little bigger and faster than Oscar at 154. Mosley beat Oscar twice at 154 and Martinez was better at 154 than Mosley or Oscar. He wasn't much better than them. He was just enough better to win.

That would be an easy night for Oscar

Oscar... close fight but Oscar drops Serg once or twice which will be deciding factor on judges' scorecards

Good fight but.... Good fight. Very good fight but Oscar would've beaten Sergio.

Oscar would have won, even with fishnets and high heels