De La Hoya vs Cotto

2008? His retirement year where he looked atrocious even vs Forbes? Come on man. Lol. That's like asking how 2005 Chavez Sr does vs Floyd or Manny. Prime for prime I could see Oscar beating Cotto pretty badly. Oscar at his best is in another class than Cotto to be frank. I just threw out a year maybe it wasn't the best. What about the Oscar that fought Floyd vs Cotto from about that time.

Depends on the weight in 2008,,, 154 Oscar beats him,, 147 it's cotto. Prime vs prime, it's a good fight but Oscar stops him in the 2nd half

2008? His retirement year where he looked atrocious even vs Forbes? Come on man. Lol. That's like asking how 2005 Chavez Sr does vs Floyd or Manny. Prime for prime I could see Oscar beating Cotto pretty badly. Oscar at his best is in another class than Cotto to be frank.

at 2008, cotto would win, prime vs prime oscar wins

Cotto probably knocks him out because Oscar lacked heart at the late stage of his career. He would have quit in his stool. And in 2008 Cotto was on the top of his game, a lot of heart and had the warrior mentality even when getting hit with plaster. And I'm Mexican by the way, from Guadalajara, Mexico.