Why is Pac vs AB a good fight, but Floyd vs AB isn't?

Because Broner is a counter puncher with a great right hand and Manny is suspect to this. Floyd isn't.

AB is easy work for Pac, and easier work for Floyd.

I'm not referring to people on here, just facebook comments from various boxing pages, if you didn't see them, then I'm not sure what to say. But believe me a lot of people objected to the idea of the fight. Well, I'm wondering why you can't see why. Floyd is the best eva and he beat Pacquiao, who is more entertaining than the running and clinching champion. You can imagine which fight will be more crowd-pleasing. Why is this so hard to understand? It's so simple.

I didn't hear anyone object to it either. If you did, show me. I totally agree with you. It's not like these two are still in their primes. And I'll never understand why Pac/May have to fight young prime tigers at this point in their careers. It's so stupid to me. Floyd can rematch Berto or fight Karass multiple times and I won't give a flying trapeze. What's so stupid is these young prime fighters not fighting each other. I'm not referring to people on here, just facebook comments from various boxing pages, if you didn't see them, then I'm not sure what to say. But believe me a lot of people objected to the idea of the fight.

Broner is better than Berto and Pacquiao is well past his prime, so I'm struggling to care. I'd enjoy it. Man berto would whoop sorry ass boner.

Ok this is a legitimate question? I agree Pac vs Broner is a good fight, but a few weeks ago when the rumour mill got spinning that AB might be facing May, I didn't hear one person say that would be a good fight? I didn't hear anyone object to it either. If you did, show me. I think whoever AB fights out of those 2 it would have been a good match. I totally agree with you. It's not like these two are still in their primes. And I'll never understand why Pac/May have to fight young prime tigers at this point in their careers. It's so stupid to me. Floyd can rematch Berto or fight Karass multiple times and I won't give a flying trapeze. What's so stupid is these young prime fighters not fighting each other.

haven't seen too many people saying it's a good fight I guess there are a good few out there who wanna see broner getting beaten up so maybe its a good fight from that perspective

Pac vs Broner isn't a good fight, people just want to see Broner lose again like he does almost every time he steps up and fights someone good

Because AB has a punchers chance against Pacquaio and against Floyd it will be a Baldimor type shut out Floyd foot work is to fast for the slow footed Broner

Its the kind of fight that allows easily, one of my favorite athletes to turn back the clock and look like his prime version Just like when Floyd faced Canelo and looked great, even though Canelo would miss him by the slimmest of margins, AB would simply get beat up. Manny is dangerous at this point with how well he can box, but thats only against certain people cuz even though he beat Bradley, he looked horrible...and TB looked like ****. Still, I like freakshows

Looking at the comments most people on here don't really sound excited for Pac/Broner

Because they know Floyd wins easy while Pac has to give the impression he's in the fight of his life

Who says Pac vs Broner is a good fight? Boner couldn't even muster enough discipline to compete with Porter, a fighter he is far more skilled than. And Pac decisively beat Bradley, who is twice the fighter Porter is. It wouldn't be a contest, just one long ass whipping from Pac for whatever length of time it lasted.

I have yet to find anyone that thinks either is a good fight

Broner is better than Berto and Pacquiao is well past his prime, so I'm struggling to care. I'd enjoy it.

Because Floyd is better than Pac. Also neither are good fights tbh, they had some intrigue at an earlier point in time but now it's whatever. Yep I could live without either fights ever happening

Because Floyd is better than Pac. Also neither are good fights tbh, they had some intrigue at an earlier point in time but now it's whatever.

Cos PAC beatsdown A.B badly with a slight chance of being ko himself while floyd just outboxes him

I don't think many are claiming it to be a "good" fight. It's certainly a step down for Pacquiao, who has just fought Bradley. Having said that, the reason people are enjoying this idea and semi announcement is just to see how badly Broner will get beat up. With Mayweather, it would've been tip tap all night long.