Mayweather vs Marciano: Who was Greater?

If honest fight fans were voting, going strictly off of resume and not popularity, the tally should be May 241 Rocky 0

Obviously Floyd. Much better resume.

Mayweather. Rocky didn’t do as much in his career and I think Floyd has a better resume overall. We’re talking Floyd’s 26 title fights/defenses in 5 divisions over Rocky’s 7 title fights/defenses in 1 division. That’s says a lot.

Marciano easily.

lol I can't even say I'm surprised at the poll after a few years on this forum. It seems more people just voted Marciano because they like him more. Even when you considered the watered down era of more belts it's still not close because Floyd has much more longevity and much more good wins. Imagine Floyd turned pro in 2006 and stepped up around 09/10 with a controversial win then retired in 2015, then compare that to his actual career.

lmao at the poll.. Wonder how many know ANYTHING about Marciano. He's winning coz he's White.. :lol1: He should be. I think I can speak on it. I've watched and read just about everything available on the dude from Broxton. I even watched that stupid f*cking movie with Jon Favreau. I bought the f*cking DVD just to be able to watch that POS.. :lol1:

It's close. Marciano didn't beat any prime super elites. Neither did Floyd. They're both equally overrated in some sense.. Yes. Overrated. One loss and they wouldn't be talked about in GOAT context.. And to be fair; another PRIME super elite could have handed them the loss needed to remove them from those sorts of discussions. You have to run the gauntlet and come out like Ali did or SRL did - on top - for true status. Any fighter that didn't go there doesn't understand the game or was too scared to take the risk and there are a lot of sober thinking intelligent "experts" that think Floyd mitigated those situations. Marciano, allegedly, was more the victim of his era.. Allegedly. For that reason you could say Marciano - although a lot of people felt he lost to LaStarza in the first fight. But it wasn't as bad as Castillo I so...

Floyd run and hug inside the ring and just fight in vegas only where the judges favor him. if he fought outside vegas he will be lost in his every fight.

I've never really watched any footage of Marciano but it seems like he's been voted higher in this thread

I can't believe that too many people voted for floyd. if floyd didn't cheat and not using PEDS then he has an argument to be better than marciano.

I like floyd more than marciano but marciano is not ducking, not cherry picking and most importantly don't use PEDS.

I didnt vote and I know who the sheep are youre one of them , nothing personal its just youth thinking they are bulletproof and know everything . Nope. If it walks, talks and cries like a duck, 99% of the time its a duck. Im no youth man, ive been following boxing since the 80s. nobody is bulletproof even floyd. nothing personal.

wow. actually the floyd nuthuggers are the sheep. real boxing fans like myself knows whats up. floyd was pretty good in the lower weights, ill give you that but he is no where is he an ATG, man. youre the 90% mayne. I didnt vote and I know who the sheep are youre one of them , nothing personal its just youth thinking they are bulletproof and know everything .

Be a different picture if they truly understood boxing to know what it is they are looking at but they dont they understand fan , which amounts to building beliefs from hype not from experience and whats real , doesnt matter what field you want to move into the idiots will make up 90% of the group . The masses are for the most part very average thinkers thats just human by nature , the lucky ones are born with traits of the 10% , the rest are sheep . wow. actually the floyd nuthuggers are the sheep. real boxing fans like myself knows whats up. floyd was pretty good in the lower weights, ill give you that but he is no where is he an ATG, man. youre the 90% mayne.

mayweather;s ducking ways transcends both die hard and casual boxing fans..:lol1::lol1: Be a different picture if they truly understood boxing to know what it is they are looking at but they dont they understand fan , which amounts to building beliefs from hype not from experience and whats real , doesnt matter what field you want to move into the idiots will make up 90% of the group . The masses are for the most part very average thinkers thats just human by nature , the lucky ones are born with traits of the 10% , the rest are sheep .

The poll is a bunch of young newbie fans talking sht as usual , its amazing how the casual fan sees things or should I say dont see things . mayweather;s ducking ways transcends both die hard and casual boxing fans..:lol1::lol1:

the poll speaks the truth. rock was greater than.......................no doubt The poll is a bunch of young newbie fans talking sht as usual , its amazing how the casual fan sees things or should I say dont see things .

the poll speaks the truth. rock was greater than.......................no doubt

Marciano without a doubt.

It is clearly Lou Cipher He was even logging in to his old account last night same time this account was posting ..he just doesnt post under the old account anymore....dude is pathetic..he posts the exact same pictures he had on his old account You stupid ass. Lou Cipher has only one account. No woman will ever be faithful to you.