who wins, 2003 heavyweight james toney vs current anthony joshua

As overrated as Joshua is, he'd beat Toney fairly easily.

bumppppppppp

Joshua wins. Toney was never really a heavyweight or even a cruiserweight. He was an extremely fat 5 foot 9 inch light heavyweight. His iron jaw and clever boxing enabled him to beat some pretty good heavyweights including a washed up Holyfield. Peters, a world class big heavyweight had too much size, skill and power for Toney and beat him twice. Joshua is much bigger and punches even harder than Peters. Toney would look like a fat midget in the ring with Joshua. My guess is Joshua would knock Toney out.

The toney that fought holyfield would win, even the toney that fought peters the first time would win vs current aj. Too slick for stiff aj

Toney would murderize him.

james toney still looked pretty good regardless of opponent for a 160lber boxing dudes like ruiz, holyfield, peter is badass imagine ggg do that lol

Holyfield was shot to sh1t even then,hell they took his license after that