Oscar when he was at 154..versus Canelo at 154..who wins

Oscar, oscar at his prime is tough fight for anyone. Has the balls and chin to hang in there.

What version?

Oscar was big and very fit at 154, with May sr in the corner Oscar TKO canelo at 11 or 12

154 oscar who fought roided vargas and mosley would destroy canelo. that left hook woul be the key..

Floyd and Lara proved that Canelo struggles with boxers. If he can't find you, he's going to have trouble. Oscar wouldn't run, but he would certainly pick his spots. Canelo would win some rounds though. 8-4, or 9-3 for ODH.

I'll admit I'm biased because I grew up on Oscar but I can't see Canelo having any chance in this matchup.

Oscar.......... Oscar was an A Level fighter. Canelo at this present time is a B Level fighter. He is improving and is good for the sport. He WANTS to be great and fears no one. This is what boxing used to be all about. Props to the kid. I am a fan.

The 154 version of Oscar that fought the roided versions of both Vargas and Sugar Shane Mosley destroys Canelo! And that was an already part-time fighter version of De La Hoya. Oscar is underrated around these parts!:nonono:

Canelo's on the same level as Austin Trout and Erislandy Lara IMO, good fighters, nothing special. I had the Canelo/Trout fight a draw and i had Lara edging Canelo by 1 point in their fight. Had Canelo beating Lara by a point, Canelo beating Trout 8-4+KD, didn't think that was close at all.

Canelo is vastly overrated. I am beginning to hate him because it was his age and hair that got him love. However his boxing ability hasn't improved. Continuously winning fights he was either expected to struggle in (Angulo) or in many people's opinion lose (Lara, Trout) tells me the opposite. Canelo is the goods, think he has improved slightly in that he targets the body more against moving targets, and I think he'll continue to grow as a fighter as well.

Canelo is vastly overrated. I am beginning to hate him because it was his age and hair that got him love. However his boxing ability hasn't improved.

oscar and it would be worse than what floyd did and im a canelo fan...

lol oscar is literally better in every dimension possible Canelo is naturally bigger, but that's it. DLH would f*ck him up badly.

It'll be tough but Oscar, too durable, Canelo should best him in close but eventually Oscar will get off and catch Canelo with something big.

The pupil is never better than the master.

Oscar would beat him... Too much handspeed and power, and that left hook would find canelo repeatedly

the golden boy will destroy him . ko round 5

IMO Oscar was faster, had more power and technically better.

Oscar, not even close. Great boxer and can hurt guys. http://a.espncdn.com/media/box/2005/0908/photo/g_vargas_275.jpg