Who do you think is the greater fighter…?

Martinez said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Paul Williams said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Pacquiao said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Yet Cotto fans see Cotto as a superhuman, that he can't be hurt. I'm sure as hell that it wasn't plaster that put Cotto down in their first fight. Yeah, they all said he was the strongest guy they fought. And that could be because he is a one trick pony, and was naturally bigger than all the other WWs. Doesn't mean he can't be outboxed and outfoxed. I'm not taking anythin away from him beating Cotto in fight 1. He did what he had to do, survived and eventually broke Cottos will.

Lol wut. Cotto easily

Cotto. More accomplished, more versatile. Margarito was a one trick pony. Take two to give one. He was just a tough SOB who had a size advantage for his weight class. Martinez said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Paul Williams said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Pacquiao said Margarito was his strongest opponent. Yet Cotto fans see Cotto as a superhuman, that he can't be hurt. I'm sure as hell that it wasn't plaster that put Cotto down in their first fight.

Cotto. More accomplished, more versatile. Margarito was a one trick pony. Take two to give one. He was just a tough SOB who had a size advantage for his weight class.

Margarito is retired as well as campaigned in one division. Cotto on the other hand, even though he lost the first fight, had many more divisions to play with. Hence more options. But as a fighter, Margarito in his prime is better but as a boxer, Cotto by a mile. Cotto's career isn't finished yet and depending on what he does, he might have a better career than majority of the boxers out there. ^^^^^^ good post green k as soon as i'm able to spread it.

Margarito is retired as well as campaigned in one division. Cotto on the other hand, even though he lost the first fight, had many more divisions to play with. Hence more options. But as a fighter, Margarito in his prime is better but as a boxer, Cotto by a mile. Cotto's career isn't finished yet and depending on what he does, he might have a better career than majority of the boxers out there.

Easily Miguel Cotto. Antonio Margarito will be a remembered as a cowardly cheat.

Margarito Ill_Will84, Lebanon, Red Cyclone 3 11.11% name and shame 'em :haha:

Cotto. Pointless thread.

Cotto for sure. Four division champ is enough for me and Margarito is a proven cheater so no contest here.

Cotto obviously has had a better overall career. But Margarito will always be his Papi.

All hail Mexican god Antonio Margarito the man who made Cotto quit not because of bad injury only because lack of heart and he knew he was getting beat up by the better man. Margarito is a good father though he took care of Cotto and Martinez left them with tender loving care

Cotto is all around the better fighter/boxer.

Cotto will be remembered as the Puerto Rican who won 4 titles in 4 divisions. Margarito will be known as the cheater who destroyed an undefeated Cotto and got destroyed by Mosley and turned Asian by Pacquiao. Not to mention getting beat by Cotto in a rematch.