who should be in a welterweight tournament if they made one ?

The top 8 WWs. Who else?

Too many good fighters at welter to just have 8 guys in tournament. Would like to see guerrero, khan, brook, garcia provodnikov, abregu in there too

1. Floyd 2. Pac 3. Bradley 4. Marquez 5. Maidana 6. Porter 7. Thurman 8. Alexander 1 Floyd vs. 8 Alexander 2 Pac vs. 7 Thurman 3 Bradley vs. 6 Porter 4 Marquez vs. 5 Maidana Looks pretty good to me. EDIT: Somehow forgot Maidana. Added.

1.Mayweather 2.Pac 3.Bradley 4.Thurman 5.Maidana 6.Khan 7.Alexander 8.Guerrero I like this but Porter needs to be in there as well. Guerrero and Alexander could face each other for the final spot or Khan/Guerrero.

Pac Bradley fight wasn't even close Pac dominated that fight

Going by Jas's bracket I think this is how it would play out pacquaio (seed number 1) vs amir khan (8) mayweather (2) vs maidana II (7) bradley (3) vs porter (6) marquez (4) vs thurman (5) Semi Pacquiao (1) vs Marquez (4) Maidana (7) vs Porter (6) Championship Match Pacquiao (1) vs Porter (6) Winner - Manny Pacquiao (1) SMH, without the voodoo spells and pulled calf, Pac was on his way to taking a beating. Bradley had Pac's head looking like a bobble head doll. Ole featherfist himself lifted Pac completely off the canvas with a shot. Your boy got lucky Bradley got hurt.

If the cold war has been resolved and Danny Garcia/Lucas Matthysse/Ruslan Provodnikov have gone up to 147 things will be interesting! Timothy Bradley vs Shawn Porter Danny Garcia vs Marcos Maidana Amir Khan vs Manny Pacquiao Keith Thurman vs Juan Manuel Marquez Ruslan Provodnikov vs Lucas Matthysse Devon Alexander vs Diego Chaves Robert Guerrero vs Brandon Rios Mike Alvarado vs Soto Karass This actually looks pretty good but i would leave Karass out and put Roberto Garcia in and match Diego Chavez against Roberto(just to get a balls out war) & Alvarado n Alexander

all fighters to undergo true olympic style drug testing if its 8 fighters then heres the match-ups : quarter finals: pacquaio (seed number 1) vs amir khan (8) mayweather (2) vs maidana II (7) bradley (3) vs porter (6) marquez (4) vs thurman (5) - semi finals imo: pacquaio vs bradley mayweather vs thurman final: pacquaio vs mayweather winner: Manny Pacquaio What about maidana ?

1.Mayweather 2.Pac 3.Bradley 4.Thurman 5.Maidana 6.Khan 7.Alexander 8.Guerrero

Floyd ain't joining no tournament he won't be comfortable not knowing who he would fight first :D

If the cold war has been resolved and Danny Garcia/Lucas Matthysse/Ruslan Provodnikov have gone up to 147 things will be interesting! Timothy Bradley vs Shawn Porter Danny Garcia vs Marcos Maidana Amir Khan vs Manny Pacquiao Keith Thurman vs Juan Manuel Marquez Ruslan Provodnikov vs Lucas Matthysse Devon Alexander vs Diego Chaves Robert Guerrero vs Brandon Rios Mike Alvarado vs Soto Karass

It's supposed to be a fantasy, why set up the dreadful reality of Pacquiao-Bradley III, Mayweather-Maidana II? :rofl: :lol1: you are right. I would switch it so we get Pacquaio (1) vs porter Mayweather (2) vs khan Bradley (3) vs maidana Marquez (4) vs Thurman Those are better match ups. Semis: Pacquaio vs Thurman Mayweather vs Bradley ( mayweather wins close decision) Final: pacquaio vs mayweather Winner : pacquaio

Going by Jas's bracket I think this is how it would play out pacquaio (seed number 1) vs amir khan (8) mayweather (2) vs maidana II (7) bradley (3) vs porter (6) marquez (4) vs thurman (5) Semi Pacquiao (1) vs Marquez (4) Maidana (7) vs Porter (6) Championship Match Pacquiao (1) vs Porter (6) Winner - Manny Pacquiao (1)

If Marquez would face Thurman by next spring, I'd bet he beat Thurman

all fighters to undergo true olympic style drug testing if its 8 fighters then heres the match-ups : quarter finals: pacquaio (seed number 1) vs amir khan (8) mayweather (2) vs maidana II (7) bradley (3) vs porter (6) marquez (4) vs thurman (5) - semi finals imo: pacquaio vs bradley mayweather vs thurman final: pacquaio vs mayweather winner: Manny Pacquaio It's supposed to be a fantasy, why set up the dreadful reality of Pacquiao-Bradley III, Mayweather-Maidana II? :rofl:

Floyd Mayweather Manny Pacquiao Tim Bradley Juan Manuel Marquez Shawn Porter Marcos Maidana Keith Thurman Devon Alexander

all fighters to undergo true olympic style drug testing if its 8 fighters then heres the match-ups : quarter finals: pacquaio (seed number 1) vs amir khan (8) mayweather (2) vs maidana II (7) bradley (3) vs porter (6) marquez (4) vs thurman (5) - semi finals imo: pacquaio vs bradley mayweather vs thurman final: pacquaio vs mayweather winner: Manny Pacquaio

Manny and Floyd :rofl: