Say Carl Froch Beats Groves Again - Greater than Joe Calzaghe

If Froch is better than Calzaghe, then Andre Ward is better than both. And Lewis is better than Holmes. Derp.

If Froch is better than Calzaghe, then Andre Ward is better than both.

Froch has the better resume by far but head to head I think Calzaghe would comfortably beat him. Based on what?

Froch has the better resume by far but head to head I think Calzaghe would comfortably beat him.

Froch. Dude has a stellar resume and should be considered an ATG based upon his no cupcakes alone. Yes, agree!!!

Bissity bump!

Froch. Dude has a stellar resume and should be considered an ATG based upon his no cupcakes alone.

I'm not from the UK and havnt read one post in this thread yet. But IMO froch is already better than calzaghe... Good post DM

I'm not from the UK and havnt read one post in this thread yet. But IMO froch is already better than calzaghe...

I'm not from the UK and havnt read one post in this thread yet. But IMO crochet is already better than calzaghe...j

Froch is far greater than Calzaghe. Calzaghe spent his career fighting bums at home before fighting the big names when they were old while Froch has gone all over the world and fought the best. Hopkins clearly beat Calzaghe IMO, so his best win was a defeat on my card.

Joe would never rematch someone that gave him a good fight like say ughhh Hopkins ... Froch would fight absolutely anybody but I doubt he'd fight a shot Jones in his last fight... the thought is actually laughable

Carl Cobra in the lead!

Still even!!!!

Calzaghe struggled with Hopkins whereas Taylor won pretty well. Styles make fights. Expert post here.

Never. Calzaghe's wins of B-hop and PRIME Kessler shyts all over Froch's resume, and that's a fact. Don't ever put Froch's name in the same sentence as Calzaghe's again. Even poll! :bottle:

i had froch winning the first fight. calzaghe's era was pure trash. first of all he barely fought anyone in it and second of all the guys that were in it sucked! lacy wouldn't even be ranked if he was around. a guy like manfredo was ranked so that should tell you how great the division was. Yup, and as well as not fighting anyone, the fights he did have were all in Wales. Compare that to a warrior like Froch who had to face the likes of Kessler, Taylor, Abraham and Ward in their backyards....

Froch fought against a prime Kessler & dropped a very close decision, let's be honest the first fight could have gone either way. The Kessler that Calzaghe beat up was green as hell. i had froch winning the first fight. calzaghe's era was pure trash. first of all he barely fought anyone in it and second of all the guys that were in it sucked! lacy wouldn't even be ranked if he was around. a guy like manfredo was ranked so that should tell you how great the division was.

Froch fought against a prime Kessler & dropped a very close decision, let's be honest the first fight could have gone either way. The Kessler that Calzaghe beat up was green as hell.