"Alien" Hopkins. "Money" Mayweather. RIGHT NOW: who has the better resume?

Corrales Castillo Judah Ortiz Maidana Canelo Hatton Guerrero all prime and he actually won all of them http://replygif.net/i/137.gif

Corrales Castillo Judah Ortiz Maidana Canelo Hatton Guerrero all prime and he actually won all of them Fair play on the part that he won them all. Canelo def wasn't prime though, more like before his prime and I'd argue Guerrero was moreso in his prime at the lower weights! Floyd definitely has one of best resumes of all time but I'm still picking Hopkins cuz he just retired, damn man hard to believe watching these two as i got older and now both are gone! Some of the last breeds of guys of that era where boxing was more than just a paycheck!

LMAO sounds like you clearly don't watch boxing at all! Here get your pencil and paper out while your at it! Class is in session! Pavlik Roy Jones Jr. Glen Johnson Trinidad Sergey Kovalev Jean Pascal Chad Dawson Tavoris Cloud ALL PRIME!! Corrales Castillo Judah Ortiz Maidana Canelo Hatton Guerrero all prime and he actually won all of them

They are so enamaored about those world champions wins when most of them were B-level fighters. Absolutely, look i respect Mayweather's accomplishments! I picked him to lose against Mosley, Castillo, Corrales and 2nd Maidana fight and he proved me wrong so i praise him for that! But don't disrespect a thorough legend like Bernard Hopkins, him facing a prime Roy Jones Jr and Trinidad trumps all of Floyd's prime opponents he's faced! I'll always give Mayweather big time praise for moving up in weight and his first fight was against the best guy at 135 at the time in Castillo!

LMAO sounds like you clearly don't watch boxing at all! Here get your pencil and paper out while your at it! Class is in session! Pavlik Roy Jones Jr. Glen Johnson Trinidad Sergey Kovalev Jean Pascal Chad Dawson Tavoris Cloud ALL PRIME!! You don't get credit for the guys who whooped your ass. And the guys he beat who were prime some would argue were never that great. Pascal, Pavlik, and Tavoris Cloud were nothing special. Hell Pavlik was over the hill by his late 20s. B Hop deserves all the credit for beating Trinidad though.

Like those guys that beat him, lol Lol he beat prime Pascal, Pavlik, Trinidad,etc. Floyd beat Prime Corrales, Castillo,Hatton

He's got nothin. And who do YOU have? State your case. Give specifics.

He's got nothin. Ha! Jokes on you, would you like egg on your face with that!

Prime opponents like who? LMAO sounds like you clearly don't watch boxing at all! Here get your pencil and paper out while your at it! Class is in session! Pavlik Roy Jones Jr. Glen Johnson Trinidad Sergey Kovalev Jean Pascal Chad Dawson Tavoris Cloud ALL PRIME!!

Prime opponents like who? Like those guys that beat him, lol

Prime opponents like who? He's got nothin.

Hopkins, he faced more prime elite opponents than Floyd but doesn't have more quantity of solid opponents as Floyd! Quality over quantity people Prime opponents like who?

Hopkins, he faced more prime elite opponents than Floyd but doesn't have more quantity of solid opponents as Floyd! Quality over quantity people

Floyd clearly has the better resume but of course he loses on here

Floyd. He is undefeated.

Time to bump this classic thread...

Thanks bro We don't always agree but I can say when we have our debates, it involves facts, our opinion and preference to support our position. Some people just flat out have disdain for certain fighters Yup. real recognize real. Sometimes we agree all day, sometimes we butt heads, but at least we bring facts and logic to the debate either way. respect.

Well said. Good post. Thanks bro We don't always agree but I can say when we have our debates, it involves facts, our opinion and preference to support our position. Some people just flat out have disdain for certain fighters

Hopkins clearly, but Mayweathers got some great wins too I don't think it's clear either way, which is what makes this topic so intriguing.

Some people are too emo on this forum....everyone has a preference but posters biase or dislike towards certain fighters is obvious I get called a hater because I am more critical of certain fighters than others. Some people's favorite fighter. Sue me. I dont expect more out of one fighter than the other. These grown azz men need to get out of their feelings and be realistic Hopkins has no where near the resume Mayweather has and its not even close. Hopkins lost to all his best opponents and biggest wins are over guys moving up. Especially at 160 and most at 175 Well said. Good post.