Amir khan/Maidana, Whose resume is better?

I would put Soto Karass or Lopez instead of Cayo or Corley. Karass and Lopez were passed it Both were shot, Lopez especially coming off a huge loss Maidana and Khan lost to two boxers near their prime Devon and Garcia Khans win over Maidana to me makes his resume a little better, as both were on the same level at the time Ortiz was a great win for Maidana Paulie and Kotelnik were great wins for Khan, one of them beat Maidana, and Paulie wud more than likley beat Maidana as well

Khan quite clearly

Maidana has definitely fought the tougher fighters. Khan has the bigger names like Zab and Paulie but neither are really that much better and Maidana probably would beat them too at this point. Maidana would not be fighting them at this point..It would have been the same point when Khan beat Paulie and Zab..Which were pretty high points in both fighters career..Paulie coming off a win and Judah coming off a big KO win..Let's also not forget about Kotelnik(who he won a belt off in dominate fashion).. I can't agree with this post..Khan's resume at this point is slightly bette..Even tho perception right now is Khan is trash while Maidana is on a winning streak..Does not change the reality that Khan is more accomplished and has fought against more champions..I'd have to go with Khan on this one..

I could not really pick one,Khan is the more accomplished fighter..Normally I would go with the more accomplished fighter..Thing is,they both have some good opponents on their ledger.. Khan has Maidana,Judah,Paulie M,and Kotelnik..I believe these are the fights worth mentioning.. While Maidana has Broner,Lopez,Karass,Ortiz and hell I'll throw in Morales..I don't believe Erik was as over the hill as MAB was.. I'm looking at a pretty even resume,so I have to bring in the accomplishments now..I'd have to side with Khan,his accomplishments at 140lb tip the scale in his favor imo..

Maidana has the better wins but he went life and death in some of them.

There's no to much in it. But if you add Lopez and Karass..then i'd say Maidana.

Amir khan's top 5 wins: Zab Judah Marcos Rene Maidana Paul Malignaggi Andriy Kotelnik Marco Antonio Barrera Maidana top 5 wins: Victor Ortiz Erik Morales Adrien Broner Victor Manuel Cayo DeMarcus Corley I would put Soto Karass or Lopez instead of Cayo or Corley.

Amir khan's top 5 wins: Zab Judah Marcos Rene Maidana Paul Malignaggi Andriy Kotelnik Marco Antonio Barrera Maidana top 5 wins: Victor Ortiz Erik Morales Adrien Broner Victor Manuel Cayo DeMarcus Corley I would put Soto Karass, Lopez instead of Cayo.