How would these two fair if they fought each other, please factor in -
Hand speed, punching power, technique, speed defiance, sturdiness of chin.
Please discuss.
Why shouldn't I? Certain fans criticize Floyd and won't give him credit for beating Canelo but Manny wouldn't have taken that fight in a million years.
They want to hold their favorite to a different standard. Just like with this Carl Froch nonsense.
You seem confused about standards. Sww is PACs 8 th weigh class. He earned a paper belt there, and dropped it on the spot admitting the weight is too much. Its only Floyd's 5th, and he's a 2x, lineal, unified reigning champ there. As such he should be ready for all comers there, and without catchweights
Pac said he will never fight again above welterweight while your boy proudly proclaimed he is the best at 154 because he is a 2 times champ there who actually fought at 154 and lied to everybody he will never weight drain his opponent but guess what?
When did Floyd proclaim this? When did he say he was the best 154 lber when he only fought there 3 times....please provide the link or you are misleading us.
As long as Manny is a active boxer and not retired, you never say never (boxers lie)...the right situation will get him there, trust me. And you are right, Floyd lied about the weight drain so why can't Manny lie about fighting at 154 lbs again.
At this point in Manny and Floyd career, it only about the right situation for them, not taking on all comers...they have both earned that right now to cherrypick in their respective careers.
They are both first ballot hall of famers
Please find that Floyd statement buddy
How would these two fair if they fought each other, please factor in -
Hand speed, punching power, technique, speed defiance, sturdiness of chin.
Please discuss.
Pac said he will never fight again above welterweight while your boy proudly proclaimed he is the best at 154 because he is a 2 times champ there who actually fought at 154 and lied to everybody he will never weight drain his opponent but guess what?
He fought at JMW 3x. Manny fought their once, and it was a "special attraction" match up. If JMW was so taxing on Floyd, then don't fight there, period.
Manny hasn't, so what are you even talking about?
So what he fought there once...he fought there and that the point AND won a belt..stop trying to downplay it.
If you are going to use the term "special attraction" for Manny, then you have to use it for Floyd 154 fights.
Anyway how do you feel Manny will fair against Froch?
But you criticized Pacquiao for being "scared" to fight above 150.
Why shouldn't I? Certain fans criticize Floyd and won't give him credit for beating Canelo but Manny wouldn't have taken that fight in a million years.
They want to hold their favorite to a different standard. Just like with this Carl Froch nonsense.
So what he fought there 1 time, the point is HE FOUGHT there and won a belt.
Never say never in this business, as long as there is money to be made and he is a active boxer (not retired)...he'll fight there if the situation is right just like Floyd does.
Floyd has only fought special attractions fights at 154 lbs against special attraction fighter if you want to use that argument...
Nonsense...
He fought at JMW 3x. Manny fought their once, and it was a "special attraction" match up. If JMW was so taxing on Floyd, then don't fight there, period.
Manny hasn't, so what are you even talking about?
Yeah, but one guy fought their 3x, while the other guy fought their once, and even said afterwards, "I'm not fighting at this weight class anymore."
So what he fought there 1 time, the point is HE FOUGHT there and won a belt.
Never say never in this business, as long as there is money to be made and he is a active boxer (not retired)...he'll fight there if the situation is right just like Floyd does.
Floyd has only fought special attractions fights at 154 lbs against special attraction fighter if you want to use that argument...
Nonsense...
Yeah, but one guy fought their 3x, while the other guy fought their once, and even said afterwards, "I'm not fighting at this weight class anymore."
Valid point, Bungalows.
Didn't even see the Floyd/Froch thread. That's a stupid ass thread also, then.
But you criticized Pacquiao for being "scared" to fight above 150. Yes. That's a retarded ass statement. Just like it would be for someone to say that Floyd is scared to fight above 150. If either takes the occasional fight north of 150 (like Manny did with Margarito and Floyd has done on occasion), then I commend them for doing so. But neither is a natural JMW. They're not "scared" to fight at JMW. They're smart. It's not their weight class. So stfu about the scared sh*t.
Yeah, but one guy fought their 3x, while the other guy fought their once, and even said afterwards, "I'm not fighting at this weight class anymore."
jmm vs sergey kovalev.....who do u think wins guys?
i like jmm in this one...but its a tossup...jmm needs to grow a pair and make this
I favor Jmm too. I've also been wondering who would win between Chocolatito and Mayweather, Rigo and Andre Ward and Bradley vs Marco Huck
Did you bring up any of these points in the Floyd Mayweather vs Carl Froch thread? Because that's what this post is a response to in case you didn't notice.
That's what's insane about this forum. Bum ass posters who attack one fighter for something and then turn around and defend their favorites for the exact same thing.
Didn't even see the Floyd/Froch thread. That's a stupid ass thread also, then.
But you criticized Pacquiao for being "scared" to fight above 150. Yes. That's a retarded ass statement. Just like it would be for someone to say that Floyd is scared to fight above 150. If either takes the occasional fight north of 150 (like Manny did with Margarito and Floyd has done on occasion), then I commend them for doing so. But neither is a natural JMW. They're not "scared" to fight at JMW. They're smart. It's not their weight class. So stfu about the scared sh*t.
It seems like we say this daily on this website but THAT'S WHY THERE ARE WEIGHT CLASSES. Do you really thing Pacquiao should be fighting above welter? And Jesus, Froch fights at 168, lmfao.
the insanity of this forum, every time I think we've hit a new high some motherf**ker pops in and raises the bar
Did you bring up any of these points in the Floyd Mayweather vs Carl Froch thread? Because that's what this post is a response to in case you didn't notice.
That's what's insane about this forum. Bum ass posters who attack one fighter for something and then turn around and defend their favorites for the exact same thing.
12y ago
manny pacquiao vs carl froch, who win? | BoxingScene Community