How does sugar shane rank all time?

he faced a tougher competition though, unlike floyd. that counts for something.

His highlight was the Margarito fight.But using the Sugar Shane moniker was a stretch.

He's not an all-timer. One of the better fighters of his era, but not a great.

He shouldn't even be in the hall of fame for taking steroids and EPO during his biggest wins over Oscar.

Defintely one of the best LW's of all time. Maybe top 40-50. He didn't really live up to the name Sugar. The other 2 sugars are BOTH normally reffered to as the greatest of all times, as far as Ray Robinson and Ray Leonard. top 40-50????please let me see your top 50 list

Hall of fame caliber fighter,, probably a top 10 lw of all time and probably a top 50 welter maybe.. Not an atg fighter

Now that his career is over....where do you rank him? Shouldn't be on the list he was a known steroid cheat we all seem how he fought with out steroids he gased out in 2 rounds when Floyd didn't let him use his steroids. His azz still got out boxed when Delahoya put a clinic on him when he was on roids

Elite level fighter in his era. I don't think he's an ATG though. Possible top 100 ATG?

Defintely one of the best LW's of all time. Maybe top 40-50. He didn't really live up to the name Sugar. The other 2 sugars are BOTH normally reffered to as the greatest of all times, as far as Ray Robinson and Ray Leonard. I agree a top 5LW IMO

Elite level fighter in his era. I don't think he's an ATG though.

Not very high on the all time list, he ranks well on the lightweights list though, but all time p4p? not really high. His biggest win against Oscar was tainted he admit to juicing later, and he was given a gift in the rematch with Oscar another fight he was using Balco for. His biggest win today is against Antonio Margarito.