Who would win a fight between Sergio Martinez and Miguel Cotto?

Stylistically it's right there for Cotto imo, but can he handle the move up in weight? Not sure.

Cotto will be the best we ever seen him for this fight. Plenty of time to train. One thing that he and Diaz said was that they did not get all the time they wanted for the Floyd fight. There should be no excuse for this fight with 6 months out. Cotto "looked" in great shape during his last fight, if "looks" are a representation of actual, then Miguel was 150% in better shape than the Trout fight where he was sluggish, slow, and plain and simple looked out of shape. If Cotto has the stamina, Sergio will be in for a complete war. Dudes saying that Cotto will be KO'd? Miguel has never been KO'd. NEVER. He has taken flush shots from some HUGE hitters like Bailey and Torres with zero result. Dont be fooled. I got Cotto via stoppage <10rd!

It's kind of a toss up I think, but I would go with Cotto on this one. Martinez didn't look very good in his last fight and with the way he always leaves his hands down below his waist I could see Cotto pulling off a win. I like this fight a lot and I really hope it gets signed.

I didn't vote because i see it as a 50/50 fight. Can't pick a winner. Both guys have their strenghts and weaknesses. Of course I'm hoping Cotto wins, but i won't be betting on this fight. His training camp photos in May will convince you Jaz..

I didn't vote because i see it as a 50/50 fight. Can't pick a winner. Both guys have their strenghts and weaknesses. Of course I'm hoping Cotto wins, but i won't be betting on this fight.

This fight comes down to what Sergio has left. He looked like he was already fading...and that was before the ring rust and stem cell stuff. All it takes is one punch though and I didn't like how Cotto was getting tagged by Delvin Rodriguez. I could see him getting rocked by a punch he doesn't see or can't take.

Sergio by knock out in the early middle rounds in a fight that Cotto is never really in. Cotto takes a massive beating against a harder hitting, naturally bigger, more athletic fighter. I expect to hear "We have weight classes for a reason" about two round in. I have Sergio by ko and will bet all my points on it if anyon wants to pm me when the fight is made. Cotto has been shot for a while and this will be a humiliating way to go out.

Who would win and how? Great match-up.Sergio by late KO.:boxing::boxing::boxing:

Casper fairly easily. Then when he wins that stupid slut will get the attention he wants. Prime for prime Sergio would of sent him back to Puerto Rico in a hearse. Even Wargarito would be in tears, who wouldn't be after watching your son go through that?

Very interesting fight, Im leaning with Cotto on this one. Late stoppage maybe?

Miguel Cotto, easily.

King Cotto by stoppage <10rd. All you Martinez fans, get your eCash ready!!! I'm coming to get it!!!

sergio Martinez by knockout.....he doesn't like cotto.....but props to cotto for taking the fight....unlike mayweather who want no parts of martinez

Prime for prime Serg appears to crush Cotto. Now? Cotto might have morrleft in the tank and even then people favor Serg. I guess that says a lot.. Love em both and if Cotto has any chance its now.

Martinez by stoppage.

What Earl said.