Which fighter had the best quality win 2013?

rigo had the best win dominated a p4p best and bradley beat the man who beat the man although in a much closer fight then garcia and adonis

I would have to say Bradley knocking off the #3 P4P fighter in JMM and taking his spot.

1. Rigo - Donaire 2. Gonzalez - Mares 3. Mayweather - Canelo

Bradley over JMM. Thread over.

Danny swift Garcia

I would say Rigo over Nonito but Danny beating Lucas was huge too. Tim is right behind them with what he did to JMM. Could easily be in front of them but I'd go with Rigo or Danny.

Yeah you have to feel for Murray. He did it in his opponent's backyard and dropped him twice. Out of interest who was rated higher, Donaire or Martinez? Really tough to say, Donaire was on like a 20 something fight win streak but I think in their last 5-6 fights (before Rigo and Murray) Sergio faced the tougher compeition, relative to their division (IMO) People say Martinez cherrypicked the likes of Barker, Macklin and avoided Pirog, etc... but they were/are top 10 MW's. People were also talking about Martinez facing Floyd, etc.. If I had to absolutely choose, I'd say I would of rated Martinez higher. tough call, though IF Murray got the W, to answer your OP, I would say Murray first and Rigo second. If Prov got the KD's, those would be my absolute top 3, without a doubt.

I think this has been Stevenson's year. He came from a position where people thought he was not even a serious contender (at 168) and now he's beaten Dawson and Cloud, and in such impressive style. Best performance of the year, Rigo's schooling of Nonito. Just a beautiful, pure boxing masterclass. Close second, Floyd's schooling of Canelo. I put it second because Floyd was a huge favourite but no-one expected just how easy he would make it look.

Jhonny Gonzalez. KO of the year, fighter of the year. Virtually nobody, but himself and his team expected him to win, and he won in the biggest way possible.

Hm... That's really tough and this is a good question. Based on the official decisions, I'm not sure I can choose one. for me it's hard to choose the overall "best" because they're all in different weight classes so personally I can't say who's better then who but from official W's I would have: Rigo over Donaire (donaire was P4P fighter) Gonzalez over Mares (mares undefeated champ) Kovalev over Campillo (campillo arguably unified champion, got obliterated) Bradley over JMM (p4p win) Wlod over Chakhkiev Adonis over Dawson But my absolute top 2, besides Rigo, if the judges weren't incompetent in Argentina this day and if the referee wasn't incompetent and called the 2-3 missed KD's would be: Murray over Martinez Prov over Bradley Obviously they didn't get official wins so I didn't include them. Yeah you have to feel for Murray. He did it in his opponent's backyard and dropped him twice. Out of interest who was rated higher, Donaire or Martinez?

Yeah I would go with Rigondeaux making what was suppose to be a Top 5 P4P Fighter at the time in Rigondeaux, look very ORDINARY!

Difficult to call/called it a close fight, meaning my prediction. The fight itself was a near shutout excluding the cheap shot KD of Donaire. My bad, thanks for the clarification.

I'd go with Rigo.

im with the majority , rigondeaux no doubt

Kev you're my boy and one of my favorite posters on here but how the hell did you score Rigo vs. Donaire as a close fight? WTF? Difficult to call/called it a close fight, meaning my prediction. The fight itself was a near shutout excluding the cheap shot KD of Donaire.

Floyd beating Canelo and Danny beating Matthysse were the highest quality wins of 2013. And Gonzalez beating Mares was a solid upset. I wouldn't call Rigondeaux's amateurs'-style - running for 10 rounds and getting dropped in the process - decision over Donaire a quality win.

The greatest win of the year was Gonzalez TKO1 over Mares, BY FAR. If there was a win of the year, that would be it. Rigondeax-Donaire was difficult to call for me, I called it a close fight. Gonzalez-Mares? I thought Mares was going to straight up knock poor Gonzalez out, especially since he's been on the slide. That was just shocking. 1. Gonzalez-Mares 2. Rigo-Donaire 3. Mayweather-Canelo 4. Stevenson-Dawson 5. Garcia-Matthysse(Came out exactly how I thought it would) Kev you're my boy and one of my favorite posters on here but how the hell did you score Rigo vs. Donaire as a close fight? WTF?

The former, "who beat the best fighter" and "best overall in your opinion". Choose one JL Hm... That's really tough and this is a good question. Based on the official decisions, I'm not sure I can choose one. for me it's hard to choose the overall "best" because they're all in different weight classes so personally I can't say who's better then who but from official W's I would have: Rigo over Donaire (donaire was P4P fighter) Gonzalez over Mares (mares undefeated champ) Kovalev over Campillo (campillo arguably unified champion, got obliterated) Bradley over JMM (p4p win) Wlod over Chakhkiev Adonis over Dawson But my absolute top 2, besides Rigo, if the judges weren't incompetent in Argentina this day and if the referee wasn't incompetent and called the 2-3 missed KD's would be: Murray over Martinez Prov over Bradley Obviously they didn't get official wins so I didn't include them.

The greatest win of the year was Gonzalez TKO1 over Mares, BY FAR. If there was a win of the year, that would be it. Rigondeax-Donaire was difficult to call for me, I called it a close fight. Gonzalez-Mares? I thought Mares was going to straight up knock poor Gonzalez out, especially since he's been on the slide. That was just shocking. 1. Gonzalez-Mares 2. Rigo-Donaire 3. Mayweather-Canelo 4. Stevenson-Dawson 5. Garcia-Matthysse(Came out exactly how I thought it would) Yeah I agree, Mares was coming off an impressive stretch , undefeated and top 10 p4p. No one and I mean no one gave Gonzales a shot in hell to beat Mares. He goes out and gets a ko in round 1.

all i know is fighters of the year should either be bradley (marquez and provodnikov with one a FOTY) or Stevenson (assuming he beats bellew) (Dawson, Cloud, Bellew)