Where do you have Joe Calzaghe at on your ATG list?

He didn't even best Hopkins That is such BS...B-Hop is a great boxer,but Joe gave him a boxing lesson.

atg 168? pretty high, top 10 obviously.

I could also have corrected "Whose". Calzaghe is at number 1 mate. Goddamn it!! Now I see. There should be a different font for sarcasm because I can never read it.

Thanks for pointing out the typo that got saved into my autocorrect. Where is Calzaghe? I could also have corrected "Whose". Calzaghe is at number 1 mate.

*Greb..... Thanks for pointing out the typo that got saved into my autocorrect. Where is Calzaghe?

Ok kid, let me school you right quick with some knowledge. From where on your prestigious list do move out sugar ray robinson, Henry Armstrong, willie pep, Joe Louis or Harry Grebb? "Whose Harry Grebb?" I hear you say, "Oops I er... forgot about him, and seem to have ricky hatton in my list too" *Greb.....

Haha...OWNAGE. Joe is in the top 100, he was a tremendous champion. There are a lot of tremendous fighters in the top 100 ATG but he has to be in there...maybe in the 50-75 range but he was no joke. The Kessler and Bika wins are major factors that substantiate Ward's legitimacy and Joe beat both way before Ward came around. Look at this nuthugger :lol1: lets see your top 100 then. Kessler and Bika are not ATG worthy wins, neither Ward or Calzaghe are close to being ATGs. He ended up being like Berto, but going in plenty picked him to beat Calzaghe. Hindsight says Lacy was, but going in he was seen as a threat. Anyways, looks like we both agree, Joe is overrated as hell. No Berto was a clearly better fighter than Lacy IMO, he just never received the hype Lacy did. It doesn't matter what was thought was going in, all that matters is the truth and the truth is he sucked as a fighter.

Top 5 ATG, no question Ok kid, let me school you right quick with some knowledge. From where on your prestigious list do move out sugar ray robinson, Henry Armstrong, willie pep, Joe Louis or Harry Grebb? "Whose Harry Grebb?" I hear you say, "Oops I er... forgot about him, and seem to have ricky hatton in my list too"

i dont. he isnt ATG worthy to me. i know he had the title for a long time but he didnt fight nobody! hopkins and jones fights dont mean much in my opinion. kessler is probably his best win. or have i missed something?

I hear many people say his resume is too thin to be an ATG. I don't know whether he is an ATG, but anywhere above Floyd is ok. He beat BH in his backyard, that is more of a risk than Floyd has ever been prepared to take.

I personally have him at about 15. Every morning i write his name on a peice of toilet paper abd wipe my azz with it.

Top 5 ATG, no question

Top 100 all time.

Common top 90 sounds about right.

No one in their right mind picked Roy Jones to win that fight. ИATAS, Ace R., aliarf, B.A. Sherif, booth-g-dawg, boxingfan405, BRAVE-HEART, Burner, Deadbirds, djsygo, dmaclv, Don Johnson, El Dominicano, Equilibrium, ericsantos, Flab, forbidden, Haglerwins, hardmanbrit, Hearnsz, hishaam15, IMDAZED, Ivansmamma, j.razor, johnkraus, Jone2ts, KantotSilog, KarlXII, kericuss, KESSLER, KJB, lanigav, larryx, Liaison, Madmar, Malicious, MANGLER, MayweatherDaMan, mECHsLAVE, mellow_mood, mspiegelo, My Name Is..., oaklandstephen, PacBoxingsVids, paul87, Pretty Boy1, Reggie Miller, roundingace, RUSTYBOXER, RwK, sjomcik, skyler, slicksouthpaw16, SOY-COMO-SOY, SpArKeD-CoLd, steptwome, Stimpy, tennmartin, The Fix, THE REED™, The Scientist, TRUCKIN, Truth, Vladimir303, Welter_Skelter, WESS, Wolfticket, xxjace, Zerwas1, `STEELHEAD Atreyu Khalil, BBFM, black.ink, BLOODGOD, Bobby Shaw, boxa__ali, bradicalusa220, Chase8400, Chr0nic, Dangerous Wlad, deeQue, Good Barracuda, GreatestIam, iron_boy, judge_jab, Jumpman23, Kball15, kingoftheland, koke07, laurensleanard, lee majors, McAlister, MMA sucks!!, mrlopez, Pele..Rjj..23, Pullcounter, superchamp, Texas Made, The Great Shark, Tmb04, VinnyCapp, WhoreUs All these people did...

Top 250 Love the fact that he exists; ****s casual fans' heads up.

http://undependentmedia.com/Images/ArticlePics/CalzagheLovinHopkins.gif

He's not even top 75. Both Ward and Froch have a better resume than Joe Cazalghe.

No where near any kind of ATG list... Hes a joke.

Lacy wasn't a bum? He ended up being like Berto, but going in plenty picked him to beat Calzaghe. Hindsight says Lacy was, but going in he was seen as a threat. Anyways, looks like we both agree, Joe is overrated as hell.