Where does Floyd Mayweather rank among G.O.A.T.?

He' CANNNOT crack top 5 He and Pac failed to face each other...

Higher than Hopkins and Manny? Higher than BH possibly but not Pac. I love all these avatars with Floyd nearly getting hit but not quite and making canelo miss. I challenge anyone to make a avatar of Canelo hitting Floyd, or making Floyd miss and punishing Floyd.

Top 15 fighter. There will never be a Floyd Mayweather Jr.

Higher than Hopkins and Manny? Yes. Bhop and Manny are great, 1st ballot HOf'ers without question. But niether is better than floyd IMO.

Thoughts? Explain. This says a lot.

Here's my top 20 of all time: 1. Sugar Ray Robinson 2. Harry Greb 3. Ezzard Charles 4. Henry Armstrong 5. Sam Langford 6. Joe Gans 7. Muhammad Ali 8. Willie Pep 9. Benny Leonard 10. Archie Moore 11. Joe Louis 12. Roberto Duran 13. Carlos Monzon 14. Eder Jofre 15. Pernell Whitaker 16. Jimmy Wilde 17. Sugar Ray Leonard 18. Bob Fitzsimmons 19. Tony Canzoneri 20. Gene Tunney Can't see any room for Mayweather there. If I made a top 50, he'd probably be between 30 and 40.

We won't know until his career is over. He should have at least four more fights. We'll have to see how those go and give it about ten years before we have a real historical perspective. The way he is going though, he'll rank pretty high on a lot of lists.

I reckon he is closing in on the top 20. Given the poll options it'll be top 50.

lol at the members that have top 5 or 10 all time.

Yeah, get rid of the top 10, and even more laughably the top 5 option. His resume is mediocre compared to other ATGs. His fans can shout about his skills until they're blue in the face, but at the end of the day it's all about resume and Floyd's just doesn't stack up. Lets hope Floyd knows this. That way he will go out in a blaze of glory and take dangerous fights, and risks. Didn't take on all comers regularly, and only fighting a decent opponent every once in a while. Canelo was a good opponent but not his equal like a Pac or Sergio. Even khan and Garcia have better resumes than Canelo. But Canelo was the natural fight out there though, as he was unbeaten and bigger.

Yeah, get rid of the top 10, and even more laughably the top 5 option. His resume is mediocre compared to other ATGs. His fans can shout about his skills until they're blue in the face, but at the end of the day it's all about resume and Floyd's just doesn't stack up. This guy has it right.

Manny has not been dominating long enough to be a top 10. His reign was short. He went from good to excellent to good. Don't ask me why?

Floyd is the best I've ever seen.

He has 4 more fights. When it is all said and done he will be top 10-5.

Higher than anyone currently fighting professionally right now. Higher than Hopkins and Manny?

Top 30 on a good day.

Higher than anyone currently fighting professionally right now.

Not top 30 34th alltime

you can't make a top 20 list with out copying. Your top 10 fighters post 60's list didnt even include Duran and he's recognized as a top 3 ATG :lol1: to Answer TS's questions he doesnt crack the top 25 Name 25 fighters greater than Mayweather. LOL You're such a troll, Maniac. :)

I respect your opinion.....but can you name me 20-25 guys who are more talented overall than Floyd. As a matter of fact name me 10. I'll wait you're confusing talent with resume.