What is your personal criteria for determining p4p and all time status?

isn't that what boxingscene is for? Lol. Good point

Good post. I do have him as p4p but based on my criteria lower in an all time status. I do think he would have great success on many missed opportunities if he would of taken them but you can't give points on coulda isn't that what boxingscene is for?

Win/loss record against fighters fought, the quality of fighters in the era, and with a sprinkle of in ring ability. Mayweather for instance could never crack a top 20 all-time list because he missed out on too many importance bouts in his best years. You don't see many welterweight champs just retire for 2 years when you have a bunch of good fights to have. Even with his strong resume below 140, he still missed guys like Casamayor, Johnston and Freitas. It's just too much to catch up on. Good post. I do have him as p4p but based on my criteria lower in an all time status. I do think he would have great success on many missed opportunities if he would of taken them but you can't give points on coulda