Who Beat Berto More Impressively - Victor Ortiz or Robert Guerrero?

I thought Ortiz was the better fight, but Guerrero was more impressive. Simply because everyone was still questioning whether or not Guerrero could stand up to that weight against that big a puncher and he not only beat Berto, but beat him up. Guerrero gained a fan in me with the way he out slugged Berto. He took him to the streets.

http://philboxing.com/news/pix/guerrero-berto.fn.08.400w.jpg http://i46.tinypic.com/1zlt20g.jpg

End of thread http://philboxing.com/news/pix/guerrero-berto.fn.08.400w.jpg

The Ghost for me he dropped Berto twice and didn't get dropped twice like Ortiz did in his fight with Berto. Plus you gotta like the way the Ghost ended that fight in the 12 round. Berto felt defeated and went to his corner. The Ghost got a little heated after the two guys were talking after the fight. He had to put Berto in check again Lol.

End of thread

guerrero did but i believe he copied it from ortiz . ...

I say Ortiz was more impressive. Guerrero didn't box at all man, he was just in there being tired, getting hit and throwing anything he had. With Ortiz, it felt like more of a boxing match. Hurt Berto in a back and forth war. Hell that's why there's a need/want for a rematch. I don't know if he should rematch Guerrero. Though, it'd be sick if he beat both of them and came back to finally fight Mayweather huh?

Victor Ortiz or Robert Guerrero - who put on the better display against Andre Berto? most excinting Ortiz most effective Guerrero.

Ortiz beat the crap out of an undefeated, WBC champion Berto that was also on roids.. It was also Ortiz first fight at 147

I say ortiz did. All teh eye damage done to berto in the Ghost fight was done by a thumbing and a head butt. Plus like some have already stated here Vic beat the better version of Berto

The Ghost raped him. Ortiz/Berto was competitive. It's clearly the Ghost.

It was close. I think Ortiz and Guerrero are at the same level at welterweight. Probably why Mayweather took Guerrero for his return bout.

It's close. I mean The Ghost just dogged Berto throughout the whole fight, didn't stop coming and he took some big shots too. Considering he didn't look that impressive in his previous fight at that weight. That said Ortiz was as impressive because everyone thought when he got knocked down that that was it and Ortiz was going to fold like before but the kid finally showed some heart and came back like a true champ. Very tough. I'd probably give the edge to Ortiz.

lets not forget Berto was gone for over a year before he faced Guerrero.Victor Ortiz beat a better version of Berto imo.

Im gonna go a specific route and judge the quality of Berto.... Victor Ortiz beat Berto when he was undefeated, undisputed WBO champ, so not taking anything from Robert, but still.

Other than the one knockdown by Berto, Ortiz-Berto wasn't that competitive. I'd say Ortiz did, though I haven't watched either fight that much.

ortiz was almost gone, glad the ref let it go but others could have stopped it on him

Robert but i loved that Ortiz showed heart in that fight so he impressed me more

http://www.gannett-cdn.com/media/USATODAY/USATODAY/2012/11/25/berto-guerrero-2012-11-25-4_3_r560.jpg?f061b7ce9937c38b702e6f308816ac2a14e2a4ec