If I get it right a p4p list is based on who would beat who, if they were to fight today, at the same weight; not on resumee.
If that's the case I agree with those putting Ward at #1.
Floyd is the best technician, but for what I've seen last year (Cotto), his legs are not what they used to be. If Ward was a WW, I would favor him over Floyd.
#1 Ward
#2 Martinez
#3 Floyd
I am unsure about Donaire, I think his fight with Rigo will show if he really belongs in the top 5 p4p. Bradley already belongs in the top 10, in my opinion, somewhere around 6 or 7.
As for Wlad, I see more than a few guys potentially beating him p4p. I'd say 9-10.
Pac lost twice last year, once by K.O. , maybe having him in a p4p list is generous, but I would put him there, above or below Bradley.
Guerrero, nowhere close in my opinion. Broner not yet, even though I think he'll be there soon.Ward lacks a natural right hand.Whether at smw or ww, prime Floyd beats prime Ward pfp.
If I get it right a p4p list is based on who would beat who, if they were to fight today, at the same weight; not on resumee.
If that's the case I agree with those putting Ward at #1.
Floyd is the best technician, but for what I've seen last year (Cotto), his legs are not what they used to be. If Ward was a WW, I would favor him over Floyd.
#1 Ward
#2 Martinez
#3 Floyd
I am unsure about Donaire, I think his fight with Rigo will show if he really belongs in the top 5 p4p. Bradley already belongs in the top 10, in my opinion, somewhere around 6 or 7.
As for Wlad, I see more than a few guys potentially beating him p4p. I'd say 9-10.
Pac lost twice last year, once by K.O. , maybe having him in a p4p list is generous, but I would put him there, above or below Bradley.
Guerrero, nowhere close in my opinion. Broner not yet, even though I think he'll be there soon.
You call them dick riders. I call them true boxing fans in the know.
and i still will call you naive as ****, lol, i still tell you this confidently , lol, broner, lol, you are surely really really naive
Ward is clearly #1, which is all that really matters
don't know how anybody else can be rated above him
based on sheer dominance/longevity, Wlad should be #2
HW sucks, but Wlad's unified and become boxing's most dominant man
i think the way you do in all of this, lol, the sheer level of dominance that wlad has done is greatly underappreciated but hes aint a american so everyone wmight rank him # 5 at best, lol, i actually remember when james toney in heavyweight, his ranking at heavyweight was sometimes was at #5 p4p, nobody gave the klits a ranking cause they were robotic or boring, lol, now the excuse is the heavyweights all sukk, lol, mayweather and ward have a bigger chance at losing than the klits, ive never ever seen ward struggle but the klits are just so much bigger than everyone else that it seems like anyone at heavyweight is in it for a massacre
Ward is clearly #1, which is all that really matters
don't know how anybody else can be rated above him
based on sheer dominance/longevity, Wlad should be #2
HW sucks, but Wlad's unified and become boxing's most dominant man
Ward is clearly the best american fighter. Floyd has been around longer, but has not done much of late. Beating SSM, and Cotto since your comeback isnt enough to be able to judge Floyd.
Floyds did so little that he is in the bottom tier 7-10 p4p
Ward is clearly #1, which is all that really matters
don't know how anybody else can be rated above him
based on sheer dominance/longevity, Wlad should be #2
HW sucks, but Wlad's unified and become boxing's most dominant man
Pac was koed but hes still a greater ATG then Floyd, and until Floyd can reach a top 10 ATG position Pac always will be, so mention the fact Pac was kod until your blue in the face it wont help Floyd.
Floyd dont fight, so hes not a top 5 p4p fighter. Top 5 potential, and isnt it sad at 36 Floyd is only seen as potentially a top fighter.
Ward beating Froch, JMM beating Pac, Bradley beating Pac is better than anything Floyd has ever done, or is likely to ever do.
Cocaine is a hell of a drug, lmfao!
1. Ward
2. Marquez/Mayweather
3. Martinez
4. Donaire
5. Wlad
6. Bradley
7. Pacquiao
8. Froch
9. Mares
10. Dawson
I go by OFFICIAL results....robberies don't count on my list
i ****in love your list, it is based on logic , not race, not biasness but it is based on what the active fighters proved in the ring, you also didnt include robberies on your list so i will say it once again , great ****in list
Pac was koed but hes still a greater ATG then Floyd, and until Floyd can reach a top 10 ATG position Pac always will be, so mention the fact Pac was kod until your blue in the face it wont help Floyd.
Floyd dont fight, so hes not a top 5 p4p fighter. Top 5 potential, and isnt it sad at 36 Floyd is only seen as potentially a top fighter.
Ward beating Froch, JMM beating Pac, Bradley beating Pac is better than anything Floyd has ever done, or is likely to ever do.
floyd EASILY EASILY EASILY ranks above pacquiao. some of these other guys you can debate but saying pacquiao is above floyd is just a massive lapse in logic
1.Mayweather
2.Ward
3.Martinez
4.Marquez
5.Donaire
6.Bradley
7.Mares
8.Froch
9.Wlad
10.Pac
Broner and Guerrero being on the P4P list is a fuccking joke...
Quote:
Originally Posted by iseah100
This might have topped the original for worst list I've ever seen. Mercito Gesta!? LMAOOOOOO! Broner shouldn't be anywhere near any top 10 lists. Donaire shouldn't be number one either. Decent list, not as bad as the first one though.
What is wrong with Mercito "No Mercy' Gesta on the list? He's 26-1 who his only lost coming in a decision that was a close fight. He's a young up and coming champion. Also Nonito Donaire many people have as P4P the #1 boxer in the world. Nonito "The Filipino Flash" Donaire was 2012 Fighter of the Year and is trying to clean up the sport, he's the only boxer to do year round VADA testing.
Not sure if you're serious, or trolling?
Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android
Pac was koed but hes still a greater ATG then Floyd, and until Floyd can reach a top 10 ATG position Pac always will be, so mention the fact Pac was kod until your blue in the face it wont help Floyd.
Floyd dont fight, so hes not a top 5 p4p fighter. Top 5 potential, and isnt it sad at 36 Floyd is only seen as potentially a top fighter.
Ward beating Froch, JMM beating Pac, Bradley beating Pac is better than anything Floyd has ever done, or is likely to ever do.
What the hell??Pac is nowhere close to the top 10 atg fighters..Before you say it,either is Mosley(in fact Mosley is light yrs away),lol...Mayweather is closer and higher up the ranking on the P4P list then Pac is..When it's all said and done and both fighters careers are over you'll see..Floyd will rank above Pac...
You have all the excuses in the world for Pacquiao, but your hero was ktfo, and nobody cares about your boxing opinion anymore-not that they ever did.
Pac was koed but hes still a greater ATG then Floyd, and until Floyd can reach a top 10 ATG position Pac always will be, so mention the fact Pac was kod until your blue in the face it wont help Floyd.
Floyd dont fight, so hes not a top 5 p4p fighter. Top 5 potential, and isnt it sad at 36 Floyd is only seen as potentially a top fighter.
Ward beating Froch, JMM beating Pac, Bradley beating Pac is better than anything Floyd has ever done, or is likely to ever do.
Thats like me saying you cant name one fighter on Floyds resume that could beat Pac. Dont say JMM now. It took him 4 attempts.
If Floyd fought as much as Pac, Floyd coiuld potentially lose to anyone. Hed probably say "i only lost cos i hurt my shoulder or hands , and ive been fighting too much recently. If you gave me longer rests in between fights i can garantee you id not lose" excuses as well
Floyd is not the best american fighter, let alone the best fighter.
You have all the excuses in the world for Pacquiao, but your hero was ktfo, and nobody cares about your boxing opinion anymore-not that they ever did.
13y ago
The top 10 pfp best fighters today! | BoxingScene Community