Where would you rank a win over Guerrero among Maywewather's other wins?

On par with Baldomir. It's a better win than Ortiz, he sucker-punched him, one of FMJ's worst victories.

Quote: Originally Posted by 1PunchKOPOW! Maybe above Judah or below Judah but above Marquez cause Marquez was a damn LW. Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android lol and Guerrero isn't? No. Guerrero has 2 fights at WW. While his body hasn't filled out yet its already acclimated and knows what it feels like to fight with that type of weight on. Marquez had never been at that weight before. As a matter of fact, he went back down in weight after the Mayweather bout. Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

right below baldomir

Floyd's best win to date is his win against prime Corrales. The Hatton and DLH victories are his 2nd and 3rd best wins. Other than those 3 fights he hasn't had a significant victory for a LONG time. A win over Guerrero would not change that.

Probably not in the top ten, he would be among the likes of Corley, Carlos Hernandez and Jesus Chavez (the two division belt holder~) ahead of those guys and a bit behind Judah (Spinks is a superior win to Berto). So a solid quality win but more of just another to throw on the pile than anything else. To most fighters it would be a lot more meaningful win~

Maybe above Judah or below Judah but above Marquez cause Marquez was a damn LW. Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android lol and Guerrero isn't?

About the same as Judah.

Where would you rank a win over Guerrero among Maywewather's other wins? Cotto (2012) at 154 Ortiz (2011) at 147 Mosley (2010) at 147 Marquez (2009) at 147 (Marquez had last fought at 135) Hatton (2007) at 147 (Hatton had last fought at 140) De La Hoya (2007) at 154 Baldomir (2006) at 147 Judah (2006) at 147 Arturo Gatti (2005) at 140 Castillo (2002) at 135 Corrales (2001) at 130 Hernandez (1998) at 130 This is where I would rank it(my ranking is based on the difficulty of the match-up within the context in which the fight took place): 1. De La Hoya (2007) at 154 2. Corrales (2001) at 130 3. Castillo (2002) at 135 4. Hernandez (1998) at 130 5. Cotto (2012) at 154 6. Ortiz (2011) at 147 7. Guerrero (2012) at 147 8. Mosley (2010) at 147 9. Hatton (2007) at 147 (Hatton had last fought at 140) 10. Judah (2006) at 147 11. Marquez (2009) at 147 (Marquez had last fought at 135) 12. Baldomir (2006) at 147 13. Arturo Gatti (2005) at 140 It will be a Castillo type win he will lose but the judges will rip Guerrero off by giving Floyd the win

1. Corrales - 2001 2. Castillo - 2003 3. De La Hoya - 2007 4. Cotto - 2012 5. Hatton - 2007 6. Ortiz - 2011 7. Hernandez - 1998 8. Guerrero - 2013 (Tentative) 9. Judah - 2006 10. Marquez - 2009 11. Gatti - 2005 12. Mosley - 2010 13. Baldomir - 2006

i would put him above ortiz,but i would also put hernandez lower and hatton higher

1. Corrales 2. De La Hoya 3. Castillo 4. Cotto 5. Mosley 6. Hernandez 7. Hatton 8. Guerrero 9. Ortiz 10. Judah 11. Marquez 12. Gatti 13. Baldomir

Above maybe Gatti and Baldo that's it... Shane while old was coming off the Marg win. Everyone else I just flat out think beats him (Guerrero)on those nights. This fight is really not that great it's just one of his decent options... Martinez (imo) being the best option followed by Canelo...then Bradley and everyone else (imo) with Guerrero being in the better part of "Everyone else"

Maybe above Judah or below Judah but above Marquez cause Marquez was a damn LW. Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

from that list, id have to say somewhere between Baldomir or Gatti, maybe lower sense both the fights at the time(maybe not Baldomir) were more interesting. the fight is BS, sad to say